This is a new offering from Ashton made by Don Pepin Garcia. The cigar presents with a mottled wrapper that is dry and somewhat reddish in color. The application of the wrapper looks acceptable and there are few veins. A roll through the fingers reveals a nice firm cigar and I do not detect any areas that may be of issue. The pre light aroma is of light wood. The pre light draw shows some light spice and some notes of cedar.
The cigar opens with a profile of light wood and some thready notes of spice. I am struck by how dry the smoke feels in the mouth, an attribute that I really do not care for. At the back of the palate there are some tangy notes that are citrus like, but the dryness of the smoke cloys the flavors. The draw is exceptional and booming clouds of smoke are hanging above my head. The burn is a bit lopsided, but it is not in need of a touch up at this point.
The first half of the cigar continues to show notes of light wood, but there is not enough depth or complexity to comment much further at this point, it is just straight wood. The smoke is still very dry and I am parched from smoking this cigar, not a nice experience. At the back of the palate there is still some tangy flavor, but I am hard pressed to identify it as anything other than citrus zest.
The final half of the cigar continues to show a profile of light wood, but there is nothing else there. I am disappointed by this smoke to this point, but it is also not terrible. The dryness of the smoke continues to be disturbing and it is causing some bitterness to creep into the smoking experience. The draw is still excellent and the burn is level.
The finish is tart with some bitterness. There are notes of citrus and dry wood.
Appearance- 83 dry and weird looking
Taste- 80 the dryness and lack of complexity and depth hurt the score
Construction- 90 an excellent performance
Strength- 80 a medium/full offering that was not complimentary to the cigar
Overall- 83.25 a very sub par cigar
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
Savinelli RyR Robusto
This cigar presents with an interesting light brown wrapper that shows more tooth than the average cigar. The wrapper shows some prominent veins and a few flaws, but the visual impression is of a firm, girthy cigar. A quick examination shows a well rolled vitola that has some tightness that might be of some concern in the smoke. The pre light aroma has some barnyard qualities, but there are some notes of spice and pepper. The pre light draw is spicy and has some notes of pepper as well.
The cigar opens with a profile that is all spice and pepper. There is a sour undertone at the back of the palate that is not the most pleasant and it detracts from the opening salvo. The draw is a bit tight, but there is not any undue labor involved in maintaining the cigar. The burn is strong and even, if a bit slow.
The first half of the cigar shows notes of spice, pepper and dark wood. There is a toasty character that borders on showing notes of charred wood, and there is still some sourness at the back of the palate. The draw loosens up nicely near the one third point. The burn also continues to show well to this point.
The last half of the cigar is disappointing. The profile transitions into a strange melange of wood and earth, but it has an underlying note that hints of wet vegetation. The sourness is even more prominent in the back half of this smoke and it is vexing. The draw is acceptable at this point and the burn continues to be solid.
The finish is sour and has notes of wood, earth and damp vegetation.
Appearance- 87 not an unattractive cigar
Taste- 78 the final half killed what would have been an average score at best
Construction- 86 the tightness in the draw hurts the score
Strength- 80 a weak medium that did not compliment the profile
Overall- 82.75 a below average smoke that I would avoid
The cigar opens with a profile that is all spice and pepper. There is a sour undertone at the back of the palate that is not the most pleasant and it detracts from the opening salvo. The draw is a bit tight, but there is not any undue labor involved in maintaining the cigar. The burn is strong and even, if a bit slow.
The first half of the cigar shows notes of spice, pepper and dark wood. There is a toasty character that borders on showing notes of charred wood, and there is still some sourness at the back of the palate. The draw loosens up nicely near the one third point. The burn also continues to show well to this point.
The last half of the cigar is disappointing. The profile transitions into a strange melange of wood and earth, but it has an underlying note that hints of wet vegetation. The sourness is even more prominent in the back half of this smoke and it is vexing. The draw is acceptable at this point and the burn continues to be solid.
The finish is sour and has notes of wood, earth and damp vegetation.
Appearance- 87 not an unattractive cigar
Taste- 78 the final half killed what would have been an average score at best
Construction- 86 the tightness in the draw hurts the score
Strength- 80 a weak medium that did not compliment the profile
Overall- 82.75 a below average smoke that I would avoid
Friday, December 25, 2009
Mi Barrio El Acere
This is a cigar made for 601 by Don Pepin Garcia. It presents beautifully with a flawless wrapper in a deep, rich brown shade. An inspection of the cigar shows it to be rolled well and I can't find any areas of issue. The pre light aroma is very rich and shows notes of tobacco, fruit and sweet earth. The pre light draw is smooth and has notes of cocoa, tobacco and earth.
The cigar begins with a profile that has serious depth. There are notes of tobacco and earth that are extremely well developed so early in the cigar. At the back of the palate there are notes of cocoa and spice. The draw is perfect and produces copious amounts of smoke. The burn is razor sharp and produces a crisp white ash.
The first third of the cigar continues to deepen, showing more tobacco and sweet earth notes. At the back of the palate cocoa notes continue to intensify. The draw remains perfect and the burn continues to be impressive.
The middle third of the cigar shows a profile shift. The core segues nicely into a sweet earth presentation. There are still notes of tobacco and some spice present as well. The undertones of cocoa at the back of the palate are still present and intense. The draw continues to impress me with me with it's flawless consistency. The burn is still strong and the ash is beautiful.
The final third of the cigar is a fantastic closing salvo. The profile shows notes of rich tobacco, sweet earth and cocoa. There is so much going on that it is difficult to discern the depth and complexity of it all. The draw and burn both continue uninterrupted in their impressiveness.
The finish is long and smooth showing notes of sweet earth and rich tobacco.
Appearance- 94 a beautiful cigar'
Taste- 96 an excellent profile with significant depth and complexity
Construction- 97 I had no issues with this cigar and it is one of the finest constructions I have seen
Strength- 90 my only area of disappointment, this could have used more punch
Overall- 94.25 a nearly classic cigar
The cigar begins with a profile that has serious depth. There are notes of tobacco and earth that are extremely well developed so early in the cigar. At the back of the palate there are notes of cocoa and spice. The draw is perfect and produces copious amounts of smoke. The burn is razor sharp and produces a crisp white ash.
The first third of the cigar continues to deepen, showing more tobacco and sweet earth notes. At the back of the palate cocoa notes continue to intensify. The draw remains perfect and the burn continues to be impressive.
The middle third of the cigar shows a profile shift. The core segues nicely into a sweet earth presentation. There are still notes of tobacco and some spice present as well. The undertones of cocoa at the back of the palate are still present and intense. The draw continues to impress me with me with it's flawless consistency. The burn is still strong and the ash is beautiful.
The final third of the cigar is a fantastic closing salvo. The profile shows notes of rich tobacco, sweet earth and cocoa. There is so much going on that it is difficult to discern the depth and complexity of it all. The draw and burn both continue uninterrupted in their impressiveness.
The finish is long and smooth showing notes of sweet earth and rich tobacco.
Appearance- 94 a beautiful cigar'
Taste- 96 an excellent profile with significant depth and complexity
Construction- 97 I had no issues with this cigar and it is one of the finest constructions I have seen
Strength- 90 my only area of disappointment, this could have used more punch
Overall- 94.25 a nearly classic cigar
Bolivar Petit Corona (Unknown Box Date)
The age of this cigar is not known with certainty, but it is believed to be from a box from 2004 or 2006. The cigar presents well with a medium brown wrapper that has very little veining. A quick examination of the cigar reveals no areas of issue. The pre light aroma has notes of leather and rich tobacco. The pre light draw shows strong notes of leather and some light spice, there is also some excellent tobacco flavor present.
The cigar begins with a stunningly complex profile that shows deep notes of leather, tobacco and some spice. At the back of the palate there is an undertone of cinnamon that adds another exceptional layer to the opening moments of the cigar. The draw is very easy, and I am surprised by this as cigars of this vintage and vitola are typically tight. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is forming in a way that is somewhat askew.
The first half of the cigar continues to impress, showing deep leather flavors as the main component of the core profile. I also note some excellent tobacco flavors, some light spice and fantastic flavors of light wood. The back of the palate is assailed by notes of cedar and I am blown away by the complexity of this little cigar. The draw continues to be excellent and the burn begins to even out.
The last half of the cigar has a core profile that continues to show leather notes, but they are accompanied by fine notes of cedar and other light wood. At the back of the palate there are still notes of spice. The draw tightens slightly at the end of the smoke, but it does not cause me too many issues. The burn, once levelled out, was as it should be.
The finish is long and flavorful, showing notes of leather and cedar.
Appearance- 91 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 93 an excellent profile that shows fabulous character
Construction- 95 one of the finest examples of this vitola that I have smoked
Strength- 92 a nice medium/full offering
Overall- 92.75 an excellent smoking experience
The cigar begins with a stunningly complex profile that shows deep notes of leather, tobacco and some spice. At the back of the palate there is an undertone of cinnamon that adds another exceptional layer to the opening moments of the cigar. The draw is very easy, and I am surprised by this as cigars of this vintage and vitola are typically tight. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is forming in a way that is somewhat askew.
The first half of the cigar continues to impress, showing deep leather flavors as the main component of the core profile. I also note some excellent tobacco flavors, some light spice and fantastic flavors of light wood. The back of the palate is assailed by notes of cedar and I am blown away by the complexity of this little cigar. The draw continues to be excellent and the burn begins to even out.
The last half of the cigar has a core profile that continues to show leather notes, but they are accompanied by fine notes of cedar and other light wood. At the back of the palate there are still notes of spice. The draw tightens slightly at the end of the smoke, but it does not cause me too many issues. The burn, once levelled out, was as it should be.
The finish is long and flavorful, showing notes of leather and cedar.
Appearance- 91 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 93 an excellent profile that shows fabulous character
Construction- 95 one of the finest examples of this vitola that I have smoked
Strength- 92 a nice medium/full offering
Overall- 92.75 an excellent smoking experience
Toro y Leon Esteli
I did some research and can't find any information about this cigar. I do know that this is a new cigar company that is about to bring it's products onto the market. I reviewed one of the other blends from this company a month ago. This smaller cigar presents in size between and petit corona and corona. It has a tawny wrapper that is thick and leathery, but it has some prominent veining. The construction feels like it might be a bit tight and there is an area that I suspect may be plugged. The pre light aroma is leathery and sweet. The pre light draw shows notes of pepper and a sweet floral tone.
The cigar opens with notes of pepper, spice and some leathery undertones. At the back of the palate there is some bitterness that is initially bothersome. The draw is smooth and easy and produces ample amounts of smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is a dirty gray.
The first half of the cigar continues to show spicy, peppery flavors that lack depth and complexity. Bitterness continues to foul the profile at the back of the palate. The draw is still wide open and producing nice smoke. The burn continues to be a touch off, but it is not causing any issues.
The final half of the cigar shows more notes of leather and spice. There is a nice creaminess at the back of the palate that has replaced the bitterness and gives a vanilla essence to the closing moments of the cigar. The draw and burn remain the same throughout.
The finish is a bit short, but shows notes of leather and spice.
Appearance- 83 very prominent veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 some early bitterness led to some reductions
Construction- 90 a well made cigar
Strength- 85 a medium cigar
Overall- 85.5 slightly above average
The cigar opens with notes of pepper, spice and some leathery undertones. At the back of the palate there is some bitterness that is initially bothersome. The draw is smooth and easy and produces ample amounts of smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is a dirty gray.
The first half of the cigar continues to show spicy, peppery flavors that lack depth and complexity. Bitterness continues to foul the profile at the back of the palate. The draw is still wide open and producing nice smoke. The burn continues to be a touch off, but it is not causing any issues.
The final half of the cigar shows more notes of leather and spice. There is a nice creaminess at the back of the palate that has replaced the bitterness and gives a vanilla essence to the closing moments of the cigar. The draw and burn remain the same throughout.
The finish is a bit short, but shows notes of leather and spice.
Appearance- 83 very prominent veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 some early bitterness led to some reductions
Construction- 90 a well made cigar
Strength- 85 a medium cigar
Overall- 85.5 slightly above average
Sunday, December 20, 2009
Partagas Master Series Majestuoso
This is a new cigar from Partagas celebrating the career of their master blender Benji Menendez. The cigar presents well with a dark wrapper that shows lots of tooth, but seems a bit dry. The wrapper also shows some flaws and there is some prominent veining. The construction seems to be ok, but might be a bit firm. The pre light aroma is sweet and has notes of hard candy and fruit. The pre light draw is tight, but shows notes of leather and brine.
The cigar opens with a profile that has heavy notes of salt and rich tobacco. The draw is too tight, but there is not any undue labor involved in the smoke. The burn is solid and produces a nice white ash. At the back of the palate there are some leathery notes, but some bitterness is taking away some of the enjoyment.
The first half of the cigar maintains a profile of salt and rich tobacco flavors. At the back of the palate there is a nice mix of leather and roasted nut flavor. The draw opens slightly and the burn stays solid. Near the end of the first half some bitterness surfaces in the main body of the profile and it causes me some concern.
The second half of the cigar transitions slightly. There are leathery notes with some flavors of roasted nuts. At the back of the palate there are some peppery notes that are present, but some bitterness still persists. The draw is now acceptable and the burn still performs well. There is a significant lack of depth and complexity in the profile throughout the experience.
The finish is bitter, but has notes of pepper and leather.
Appearance- 83 veining and flaws hurt the score
Taste- 84 bitterness and lack of depth and complexity hurt the overall impression
Construction- 82 the tight draw in the early stages hinder the cigar
Strength- 85 a very average medium
Overall- 83.5 a below average cigar with a ten dollar price tag
The cigar opens with a profile that has heavy notes of salt and rich tobacco. The draw is too tight, but there is not any undue labor involved in the smoke. The burn is solid and produces a nice white ash. At the back of the palate there are some leathery notes, but some bitterness is taking away some of the enjoyment.
The first half of the cigar maintains a profile of salt and rich tobacco flavors. At the back of the palate there is a nice mix of leather and roasted nut flavor. The draw opens slightly and the burn stays solid. Near the end of the first half some bitterness surfaces in the main body of the profile and it causes me some concern.
The second half of the cigar transitions slightly. There are leathery notes with some flavors of roasted nuts. At the back of the palate there are some peppery notes that are present, but some bitterness still persists. The draw is now acceptable and the burn still performs well. There is a significant lack of depth and complexity in the profile throughout the experience.
The finish is bitter, but has notes of pepper and leather.
Appearance- 83 veining and flaws hurt the score
Taste- 84 bitterness and lack of depth and complexity hurt the overall impression
Construction- 82 the tight draw in the early stages hinder the cigar
Strength- 85 a very average medium
Overall- 83.5 a below average cigar with a ten dollar price tag
Friday, December 18, 2009
Padilla Signature 1932 2009 Limited Edition Salomon Oscuro
This is a huge cigar in a very rare vitola with an oscuro wrapper. The cigar is chunky and draped in an oily oscuro wrapper. The wrapper has no apparent flaws and is expertly applied. The construction appears to be solid and I do not detect any areas that would cause an issue. The pre light aroma is of tobacco, earth and some light spice. The pre light draw has an earthy sweetness and a hint of ginger.
The cigar begins with a profile of rich tobacco and some notes of spice. There is an earthy sweetness at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent, which is surprising to me for a cigar of this size. The burn is lopsided, but not causing some issues.
The first third of the cigar shows a profile of rich tobacco, spice and some meaty overtones that are interesting. There is some salt and mint at the back of the palate that is strange, but not off putting. The draw has stayed near perfect, but the burn has continued to deteriorate and may require a touch up (we all know how I feel about touch ups).
The middle third continues to show a profile of tobacco and spice, but is showing some minty notes as well. There is still some salt at the back of the palate. The burn has to be retouched twice in this segment of the cigar, and I am disappointed. The draw continues to stay strong to this point.
The final third shows a profile of pepper, pepper and more pepper. There is still some earthy sweetness and mint showing through at the back of the palate. The burn has continued to need retouching throughout the final two thirds, but the draw has been excellent.
The finish is lingering and shows notes of pepper, earth and spice.
Appearance- 94 it is impossible not to be impressed with this cigar
Taste- 88 not bad, but the profile lacked some depth and some of the flavors were not complimentary to one another
Construction- 85 the burn issues hurt the score
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full that could use more pop
Overall- 88.75 a nice smoke, with nice aging potential
The cigar begins with a profile of rich tobacco and some notes of spice. There is an earthy sweetness at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent, which is surprising to me for a cigar of this size. The burn is lopsided, but not causing some issues.
The first third of the cigar shows a profile of rich tobacco, spice and some meaty overtones that are interesting. There is some salt and mint at the back of the palate that is strange, but not off putting. The draw has stayed near perfect, but the burn has continued to deteriorate and may require a touch up (we all know how I feel about touch ups).
The middle third continues to show a profile of tobacco and spice, but is showing some minty notes as well. There is still some salt at the back of the palate. The burn has to be retouched twice in this segment of the cigar, and I am disappointed. The draw continues to stay strong to this point.
The final third shows a profile of pepper, pepper and more pepper. There is still some earthy sweetness and mint showing through at the back of the palate. The burn has continued to need retouching throughout the final two thirds, but the draw has been excellent.
The finish is lingering and shows notes of pepper, earth and spice.
Appearance- 94 it is impossible not to be impressed with this cigar
Taste- 88 not bad, but the profile lacked some depth and some of the flavors were not complimentary to one another
Construction- 85 the burn issues hurt the score
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full that could use more pop
Overall- 88.75 a nice smoke, with nice aging potential
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Rocky Patel Olde World Reserve Lancero
This is a rare incarnation of this blend, and I have seldom seen the lancero size available anywhere. The cigar presents well with a dark, nearly vein free wrapper. The construction seems to be exceptional, in my experience most cigars of this size seem as though they will be too tight. The pre light aroma has notes of cocoa and rich tobacco. The pre light draw shows rich tobacco notes and an earthy sweetness.
The cigar opens with full powered blasts of rich tobacco flavors, there are some sweet cocoa undertones that are intriguing. The draw is exceptional for a cigar of this size, and there is no labor involved in producing acceptable amounts of smoke. The burn is sharp and produces a crisp white ash.
The first third of the cigar shows excellent notes of rich tobacco, earth and cocoa. The depth of the profile is exceptional, but some complexity is missing. At the back of the palate there are some metallic, chemical flavors. The draw is still nearly perfect and the burn is performing well.
The middle third of the cigar continues to show nice depth, with flavors of rich tobacco, earth and some nice spice. The back of the palate issues are still present and the chemical, metallic notes are hurting the experience. The draw and burn continue to perform very well.
The final third of the cigar deteriorates. The chemical, metallic notes become more prominent and the rest of the profile takes on a charred characteristic. The burn and draw are still excellent.
The finish is short and bitter with metallic and medicinal qualities.
Appearance- 91 an attractive cigar, that is a bit lopsided
Taste- 82 some winning notes up front, that deteriorate in the body of the cigar
Construction- 95 this cigar performs very well
Strength- 85 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 88.25 based on appearance and construction, otherwise this is a must miss
The cigar opens with full powered blasts of rich tobacco flavors, there are some sweet cocoa undertones that are intriguing. The draw is exceptional for a cigar of this size, and there is no labor involved in producing acceptable amounts of smoke. The burn is sharp and produces a crisp white ash.
The first third of the cigar shows excellent notes of rich tobacco, earth and cocoa. The depth of the profile is exceptional, but some complexity is missing. At the back of the palate there are some metallic, chemical flavors. The draw is still nearly perfect and the burn is performing well.
The middle third of the cigar continues to show nice depth, with flavors of rich tobacco, earth and some nice spice. The back of the palate issues are still present and the chemical, metallic notes are hurting the experience. The draw and burn continue to perform very well.
The final third of the cigar deteriorates. The chemical, metallic notes become more prominent and the rest of the profile takes on a charred characteristic. The burn and draw are still excellent.
The finish is short and bitter with metallic and medicinal qualities.
Appearance- 91 an attractive cigar, that is a bit lopsided
Taste- 82 some winning notes up front, that deteriorate in the body of the cigar
Construction- 95 this cigar performs very well
Strength- 85 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 88.25 based on appearance and construction, otherwise this is a must miss
Monday, December 14, 2009
Casa Magna Corona
This is the much ballyhooed cigar of the year, from last year, according to the "pros" at Cigar Aficionado. They rated a different size, but the point is that a major publication believed that this was the cigar of the year. It presents well with a beautiful dark brown wrapper that is exceptionally oily and shimmering with the beginnings of plume crystals. There are few veins and the construction feels firm, but not unduly so. The pre light aroma is of rich cedar and there is light coffee notes with some floral hints. The pre light draw shows some light spice, cedar and floral notes, I note that the draw is a bit firm.
The cigar begins with a core profile of cedar and a sweet earthy spice. There are some notes at the back of the palate that are bit sour and thus cloying some of the essence of the core profile. The draw is tight, but not horribly so, just a bit too firm for my liking. The burn is sharp and a bright white ash is forming.
The first half of the cigar is awash with solid cedar and earthy spice essence. The sourness at the back of the palate is still present, particularly through the nose. The draw has loosened slightly and is becoming more acceptable as I progress. The burn is remarkable and the ash is firm, white and solid.
The final half of the cigar shows more notes of cedar and sweet earthy spice, there are some notes of coffee and a nice tobacco flavor at the back of the palate. However, the sour notes have not fully retreated from the experience and I have to consider them against the rest of the experience. The draw is now acceptable and the burn has stayed consistent.
The finish is not unpleasant, but leaves me wanting something more complex and bold. There are notes of coffee and earth, but there is not enough depth to fully contemplate giving a great score to the smoke.
Appearance- 94 a very good looking cigar
Taste- 82 the sour notes really detract from this experience
Construction- 86 tight draws for the first half hurt this score, otherwise excellent
Strength- 85 an unremarkable medium smoke
Overall- 86.75 saved by appearance, no cigar of the year honors from me!
The cigar begins with a core profile of cedar and a sweet earthy spice. There are some notes at the back of the palate that are bit sour and thus cloying some of the essence of the core profile. The draw is tight, but not horribly so, just a bit too firm for my liking. The burn is sharp and a bright white ash is forming.
The first half of the cigar is awash with solid cedar and earthy spice essence. The sourness at the back of the palate is still present, particularly through the nose. The draw has loosened slightly and is becoming more acceptable as I progress. The burn is remarkable and the ash is firm, white and solid.
The final half of the cigar shows more notes of cedar and sweet earthy spice, there are some notes of coffee and a nice tobacco flavor at the back of the palate. However, the sour notes have not fully retreated from the experience and I have to consider them against the rest of the experience. The draw is now acceptable and the burn has stayed consistent.
The finish is not unpleasant, but leaves me wanting something more complex and bold. There are notes of coffee and earth, but there is not enough depth to fully contemplate giving a great score to the smoke.
Appearance- 94 a very good looking cigar
Taste- 82 the sour notes really detract from this experience
Construction- 86 tight draws for the first half hurt this score, otherwise excellent
Strength- 85 an unremarkable medium smoke
Overall- 86.75 saved by appearance, no cigar of the year honors from me!
Friday, December 11, 2009
Vegas Robaina Unicos (Unknown Box Date)
This cigar presents in a very pointy torpedo shape. The wrapper is a deep brown, that is somewhat dry, but has some toothy qualities. The roll feels a touch loose, but I can't detect any areas that are too soft and I do not anticipate a problem. The pre light aroma is satisfyingly like a barnyard. The pre light draw shows some floral notes, but there is also a little bite.
The cigar begins with a profile that is floral, but there are undertones of wood and some spice. The smoke is dry and has some definite bite at the back of the palate. The draw is very loose, and that is not typical with cigars of this origin. The burn is a bit off, but there is a nice shoulder that suggests some pretty lengthy aging.
The first third of the cigar continues to show some notes that are floral, but the woody undertones are becoming prominent as the cigar progresses. The bite at the back of the palate is also showing more influence as the smoke moves on. The draw has stayed loose and the burn is still showing some lopsided qualities, but is maintaining a nice shoulder.
The middle third of the cigar begins to show some notes of pepper and more spice, but those flavors are countered by some notes of charred wood that are bothersome. The back of the palate experience continues to have some unnecessary bite that is bordering on bitter. The draw has loosened further and heat begins to show in the smoke. The burn has evened, but still shows a nice shoulder.
The final third of the cigar is disappointing. The profile is predominantly of charred wood, there are some strands of pepper and spice, but they are not enough to hold on to. The draw and burn remain the same, but the heat in the smoke is distracting by this point.
The finish is short and bitter, there are some notes of charred wood and burned out floral aftertaste.
Appearance- 87 a nice looking cigar, but dryness hurts the overall appeal
Taste- 80 too much bite not enough depth and complexity in the profile
Construction- 84 the loose draw caused issues
Strength- 82 a below average medium
Overall- 83.25 below average, perhaps another fermentation through aging would be helpful
The cigar begins with a profile that is floral, but there are undertones of wood and some spice. The smoke is dry and has some definite bite at the back of the palate. The draw is very loose, and that is not typical with cigars of this origin. The burn is a bit off, but there is a nice shoulder that suggests some pretty lengthy aging.
The first third of the cigar continues to show some notes that are floral, but the woody undertones are becoming prominent as the cigar progresses. The bite at the back of the palate is also showing more influence as the smoke moves on. The draw has stayed loose and the burn is still showing some lopsided qualities, but is maintaining a nice shoulder.
The middle third of the cigar begins to show some notes of pepper and more spice, but those flavors are countered by some notes of charred wood that are bothersome. The back of the palate experience continues to have some unnecessary bite that is bordering on bitter. The draw has loosened further and heat begins to show in the smoke. The burn has evened, but still shows a nice shoulder.
The final third of the cigar is disappointing. The profile is predominantly of charred wood, there are some strands of pepper and spice, but they are not enough to hold on to. The draw and burn remain the same, but the heat in the smoke is distracting by this point.
The finish is short and bitter, there are some notes of charred wood and burned out floral aftertaste.
Appearance- 87 a nice looking cigar, but dryness hurts the overall appeal
Taste- 80 too much bite not enough depth and complexity in the profile
Construction- 84 the loose draw caused issues
Strength- 82 a below average medium
Overall- 83.25 below average, perhaps another fermentation through aging would be helpful
Wednesday, December 9, 2009
Camacho Select Robusto
This cigar presents with an interesting wrapper that is a chestnut brown that has a lot of tooth. There are some prominent veins, but the cigar appears to be well made as I detect no areas of concern. The pre light aroma is sweet and has hints of fruit, but a slightly sour undertone. The pre light draw shows notes of tobacco and wood.
The cigar begins with a shallow profile of wood and light tobacco notes. There is a very dry quality to the smoke and it leaves the palate feeling somewhat parched. The draw is excellent and the burn is sharp, producing a nice crisp ash. At the back of the palate the dryness leads to some bitterness and some sharp aspirin like notes.
The first half of the cigar shows little development and maintains a dry and somewhat bitter quality. The profile has notes of wood and tobacco, but the lack of depth and complexity are vexing. The draw maintains a very high quality and the burn stays sharp.
The final half of the cigar shows nothing further and maintains a straightforward profile of tobacco and wood. There are some charred flavors showing through at the back of the palate and the overall dry texture of the smoke continues to bother me. The draw and burn have stayed consistent.
The finish is sharp, bitter and dryer still. There are notes of charred wood and light tobacco.
Appearance- 86 veining hurts the score
Taste- 79 the dry and bitter notes prohibit a higher score
Construction- 92 a well made cigar that performed very well
Strength- 85 an average medium offering
Overall- 85.5 saved by construction
The cigar begins with a shallow profile of wood and light tobacco notes. There is a very dry quality to the smoke and it leaves the palate feeling somewhat parched. The draw is excellent and the burn is sharp, producing a nice crisp ash. At the back of the palate the dryness leads to some bitterness and some sharp aspirin like notes.
The first half of the cigar shows little development and maintains a dry and somewhat bitter quality. The profile has notes of wood and tobacco, but the lack of depth and complexity are vexing. The draw maintains a very high quality and the burn stays sharp.
The final half of the cigar shows nothing further and maintains a straightforward profile of tobacco and wood. There are some charred flavors showing through at the back of the palate and the overall dry texture of the smoke continues to bother me. The draw and burn have stayed consistent.
The finish is sharp, bitter and dryer still. There are notes of charred wood and light tobacco.
Appearance- 86 veining hurts the score
Taste- 79 the dry and bitter notes prohibit a higher score
Construction- 92 a well made cigar that performed very well
Strength- 85 an average medium offering
Overall- 85.5 saved by construction
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Xikar HC Colorado Habano Toro
This is a new cigar from the famed accessory maker, it replaces the Defiance cigar (I would recommend getting some Defiance cigars if you can still find them, they were excellent). This cigar presents well with a Colorado Habano wrapper that does not have the typical reddish hue that I expect, but is more of a deep chocolate brown. There are some prominent veins in the wrapper and the roll seems a bit loose. The pre light aroma is of dark fruit, I sense black cherry. The pre light draw is a bit tight, which runs counter to the looseness of the roll, and is a bit confusing when it shows notes of spice, fruit and some sort of weird chemical/solvent undertone.
The cigar opens with notes of black cherry and spice, there is a bit of a clean tobacco flavor in the mix, but there is a definite chemical underpinning to the profile that is bothersome. The draw is a bit tight, but I am not having any real issues. The burn is even and produces a nice gray ash, that is firm.
The first third of the cigar progresses with a profile that has notes of dark fruit and floral sweetness. The chemical, almost medicinal, undertone is still in the profile and it is nearly enough to make me put the smoke down. The draw is still tight, but the burn is excellent. I perservere against my better judgement at this point.
The middle third of the cigar picks up some clean tobacco notes with hints of dark fruit and some more layers of floral essences. The chemical flavors have faded some and the profile is gaining some positive points, but still lacking in depth and complexity. The draw has opened up perceptibly and the result is more smoke, but the same flavors that lack depth. The burn is still above average at this point.
The final third of the cigar spirals out of control. The profile shows notes of charred wood and paper. The profile takes on a an acrid, acidic overtone and the chemical flavors are in my face. The draw has completely opened up allowing me to partake in the foul and malodorous experience in full effect. The burn is still performing well.
The finish is short, bitter, charred and acidic.
Appearance- 86 an above average looking cigar
Taste- 74 saved somewhat by the middle third
Construction- 84 early draw issues were a small problem
Strength- 70 too difficult to discern within the sub par profile
Overall- 78.5 they should have saved the tobacco for sacrifice in the next hurricane
The cigar opens with notes of black cherry and spice, there is a bit of a clean tobacco flavor in the mix, but there is a definite chemical underpinning to the profile that is bothersome. The draw is a bit tight, but I am not having any real issues. The burn is even and produces a nice gray ash, that is firm.
The first third of the cigar progresses with a profile that has notes of dark fruit and floral sweetness. The chemical, almost medicinal, undertone is still in the profile and it is nearly enough to make me put the smoke down. The draw is still tight, but the burn is excellent. I perservere against my better judgement at this point.
The middle third of the cigar picks up some clean tobacco notes with hints of dark fruit and some more layers of floral essences. The chemical flavors have faded some and the profile is gaining some positive points, but still lacking in depth and complexity. The draw has opened up perceptibly and the result is more smoke, but the same flavors that lack depth. The burn is still above average at this point.
The final third of the cigar spirals out of control. The profile shows notes of charred wood and paper. The profile takes on a an acrid, acidic overtone and the chemical flavors are in my face. The draw has completely opened up allowing me to partake in the foul and malodorous experience in full effect. The burn is still performing well.
The finish is short, bitter, charred and acidic.
Appearance- 86 an above average looking cigar
Taste- 74 saved somewhat by the middle third
Construction- 84 early draw issues were a small problem
Strength- 70 too difficult to discern within the sub par profile
Overall- 78.5 they should have saved the tobacco for sacrifice in the next hurricane
Monday, December 7, 2009
Perdomo Habano Connecticut Robusto
This is a beast of a robusto with a tawny blond wrapper that is oily and nearly vein free. There are no flaws in the appearance of this cigar and a quick inspection shows that there should not be any construction issues. The pre light aroma is of light spice and a floral sweetness. The pre light draw also has notes of floral sweetness and a peppery note at the back of the palate.
The cigar opens with a blast of peppery notes and a floral sweetness at the back of the palate. I am surprised by the power of this cigar, as a Connecticut wrapper is usually more mild. The draw is excellent and the burn is sharp.
The first third of the cigar continues to show notes of pepper and a floral sweetness. At the back of the palate the smoke is heavy and has some notes of light wood that seems a bit dusty. The draw and burn continue to perform well.
The second third of the cigar settles down and shows notes of light spice, light wood and some nutty flavors. At the back of the palate there are still some floral notes, but the finish still feels dusty on the palate. The draw continues to perform well, but the burn dies out and a retouch is necessary.
The final third of the smoke shows notes of spice, wood and nuts. At the back of the palate the floral sweetness has started to turn grassy and it hurts the profile. I find myself wanting more depth and complexity from this smoke. The draw is still excellent, but the burn has died again and it is beginning to be irritating.
The finish is sharp with notes of pepper and grass.
Appearance- 91 an excellent looking cigar
Taste- 84 I expected more here, grassy notes in the final third hurt the score
Construction- 85 the burn issues detract from the score here
Strength- 87 a nice full smoke that was surprising
Overall- 86.75 not bad, but saved by appearance
The cigar opens with a blast of peppery notes and a floral sweetness at the back of the palate. I am surprised by the power of this cigar, as a Connecticut wrapper is usually more mild. The draw is excellent and the burn is sharp.
The first third of the cigar continues to show notes of pepper and a floral sweetness. At the back of the palate the smoke is heavy and has some notes of light wood that seems a bit dusty. The draw and burn continue to perform well.
The second third of the cigar settles down and shows notes of light spice, light wood and some nutty flavors. At the back of the palate there are still some floral notes, but the finish still feels dusty on the palate. The draw continues to perform well, but the burn dies out and a retouch is necessary.
The final third of the smoke shows notes of spice, wood and nuts. At the back of the palate the floral sweetness has started to turn grassy and it hurts the profile. I find myself wanting more depth and complexity from this smoke. The draw is still excellent, but the burn has died again and it is beginning to be irritating.
The finish is sharp with notes of pepper and grass.
Appearance- 91 an excellent looking cigar
Taste- 84 I expected more here, grassy notes in the final third hurt the score
Construction- 85 the burn issues detract from the score here
Strength- 87 a nice full smoke that was surprising
Overall- 86.75 not bad, but saved by appearance
Saturday, December 5, 2009
Dunhill Signed Range Robusto
This is another offering at the high end of the retail spectrum. This is supposedly a departure from the mild cigar usually produced under the Dunhill label. The cigar presents well with a dark natural wrapper that has few veins. The roll seems to be a bit loose, but there are no soft areas that might create an issue. The pre light aroma is slightly sour, but has notes of nuts of spice. The pre light draw shows spice and floral sweetness.
The cigar opens with a profile of spice mixed with some flavors of dry wood. At the back of the palate there is a dry floral sweetness that has a touch of sourness. The draw is excellent and produces ample smoke with minimal effort. The burn is sharp and produces a dirty gray ash that is slightly flaky.
The first half of the cigar shows notes of dry wood and light spice. At the back of the palate there continues to be a dry floral essence that is turning slightly bitter. The draw and burn continue to perform well, but the ash is still flaky.
The final half of the cigar develops with notes of roasted nuts and dry wood. At the back of the palate the floral note remains bitter, but there is some spice that is interesting. The draw and burn stay consistent, but the profile lacks complexity and depth.
The finish is a touch short and bitter. There are floral and nutty notes, but there are some grassy overtones.
Appearance- 87 an acceptable looking cigar
Taste- 82 bitterness hurts and there is a lack of complexity and depth
Construction- 89 aside from the flaky ash the cigar performed well
Strength- 84 an unremarkable medium
Overall- 85.5 just an average smoke with below average flavors
The cigar opens with a profile of spice mixed with some flavors of dry wood. At the back of the palate there is a dry floral sweetness that has a touch of sourness. The draw is excellent and produces ample smoke with minimal effort. The burn is sharp and produces a dirty gray ash that is slightly flaky.
The first half of the cigar shows notes of dry wood and light spice. At the back of the palate there continues to be a dry floral essence that is turning slightly bitter. The draw and burn continue to perform well, but the ash is still flaky.
The final half of the cigar develops with notes of roasted nuts and dry wood. At the back of the palate the floral note remains bitter, but there is some spice that is interesting. The draw and burn stay consistent, but the profile lacks complexity and depth.
The finish is a touch short and bitter. There are floral and nutty notes, but there are some grassy overtones.
Appearance- 87 an acceptable looking cigar
Taste- 82 bitterness hurts and there is a lack of complexity and depth
Construction- 89 aside from the flaky ash the cigar performed well
Strength- 84 an unremarkable medium
Overall- 85.5 just an average smoke with below average flavors
Friday, December 4, 2009
Ashton VSG Robusto
This is a classic cigar that has been available at the top end of the market for years. The selection I have chosen has over a year of humidor age on it. The cigar is visually appealing with a nice dark wrapper that has few veins and zero flaws. The construction feels firm, but not too firm, and I don't anticipate any issues smoking this cigar. The pre light aroma is light and has notes of wood and crisp tobacco. The pre light draw is dry and woody with notes of clean tobacco and pepper.
The cigar opens with notes of wood, clean tobacco notes and hints of light pepper and spice. The draw is exceptional, and the burn is producing a sharp, crisp white ash. At the back of the palate the pepper note is more prominent, but I find myself wanting more depth up front.
At the one third point the cigar has developed nicely, but is still a medium offering. The profile shows notes of wood, spice and pepper. At the back of the palate there are some light notes of creamed coffee and a brown sugar like sweetness. The draw is still performing very well and the ease of this smoke adds to the enjoyability. The burn is still sharp and the ash is holding to well past the one third point of the cigar.
The middle third is still performing well but the profile is losing some of it's zest. There are notes of wood, pepper and tobacco but the depth is lacking and discouraging. The burn and draw have remained constant and I am still struck by the quality performance of this cigar.
The final third picks up some steam and is somewhere beyond medium, but not quite full in strength. The profile continues to show notes of wood, spice, pepper and tobacco. I am still wanting more complexity and depth from this cigar to the end. The burn and draw have stayed consistent.
The finish is smooth and long showing notes of pepper and clean tobacco flavors.
Appearance- 92 an excellent cigar to behold
Taste- 87 lacking in depth and complexity
Construction- 95 an excellent example of the craft
Strength- 88 could have used more power throughout
Overall- 90.5 overall an average tasting cigar buoyed by a strong performance construction wise
The cigar opens with notes of wood, clean tobacco notes and hints of light pepper and spice. The draw is exceptional, and the burn is producing a sharp, crisp white ash. At the back of the palate the pepper note is more prominent, but I find myself wanting more depth up front.
At the one third point the cigar has developed nicely, but is still a medium offering. The profile shows notes of wood, spice and pepper. At the back of the palate there are some light notes of creamed coffee and a brown sugar like sweetness. The draw is still performing very well and the ease of this smoke adds to the enjoyability. The burn is still sharp and the ash is holding to well past the one third point of the cigar.
The middle third is still performing well but the profile is losing some of it's zest. There are notes of wood, pepper and tobacco but the depth is lacking and discouraging. The burn and draw have remained constant and I am still struck by the quality performance of this cigar.
The final third picks up some steam and is somewhere beyond medium, but not quite full in strength. The profile continues to show notes of wood, spice, pepper and tobacco. I am still wanting more complexity and depth from this cigar to the end. The burn and draw have stayed consistent.
The finish is smooth and long showing notes of pepper and clean tobacco flavors.
Appearance- 92 an excellent cigar to behold
Taste- 87 lacking in depth and complexity
Construction- 95 an excellent example of the craft
Strength- 88 could have used more power throughout
Overall- 90.5 overall an average tasting cigar buoyed by a strong performance construction wise
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Maduro Robusto
This is a new offering from RyJ. The cigar presents well with a muted wrapper that is somewhat less dark than I would anticipate from a maduro cigar. There is some prominent veining and the cigar appears and feels a little dry. There is some significant tooth to the wrapper and the cigar feels firm, but not too firm. The pre light aroma is of light tobacco and citrus. The pre light draw shows notes of cocoa and earth.
The cigar begins with a very mild, but flavorful, profile. There are notes of light cocoa and nice toasty tobacco flavors. The draw is smooth and easy. The burn is sharp and produces a nice white ash.
The first two inches of the cigar develop with a profile of cocoa, earth and tobacco notes. At the back of the palate the smoke tastes a bit dry and is somewhat sharp. The draw and burn stay consistent for the first several minutes.
At the halfway point the cigar continues to show cocoa notes and some other floral sweetness. There is still a tobacco tinge at the back of the palate, but the smoke is still a bit dry. There is a lack of depth and complexity, and I find that I am wanting more from this smoke.
The final half of the cigar remains much the same. There are notes of cocoa, earth and there is still some floral sweetness at the back of the palate. The smoke remains dry and a bit sharp at the back of the palate. The burn and draw have stayed consistent. The was a large run at the end of the cigar that was not worth touching up.
The finish is a touch short, but has some sweet notes and light earth dominates.
Appearance- 86 the veins and dry appearance hurt the score
Taste- 83 the dry smoke and lack of depth and complexity hurt the score
Construction- 88 the run at the end hurt the score
Strength- 86 a nice medium smoke
Overall- 85.75 slightly above average, could have used more depth and complexity
The cigar begins with a very mild, but flavorful, profile. There are notes of light cocoa and nice toasty tobacco flavors. The draw is smooth and easy. The burn is sharp and produces a nice white ash.
The first two inches of the cigar develop with a profile of cocoa, earth and tobacco notes. At the back of the palate the smoke tastes a bit dry and is somewhat sharp. The draw and burn stay consistent for the first several minutes.
At the halfway point the cigar continues to show cocoa notes and some other floral sweetness. There is still a tobacco tinge at the back of the palate, but the smoke is still a bit dry. There is a lack of depth and complexity, and I find that I am wanting more from this smoke.
The final half of the cigar remains much the same. There are notes of cocoa, earth and there is still some floral sweetness at the back of the palate. The smoke remains dry and a bit sharp at the back of the palate. The burn and draw have stayed consistent. The was a large run at the end of the cigar that was not worth touching up.
The finish is a touch short, but has some sweet notes and light earth dominates.
Appearance- 86 the veins and dry appearance hurt the score
Taste- 83 the dry smoke and lack of depth and complexity hurt the score
Construction- 88 the run at the end hurt the score
Strength- 86 a nice medium smoke
Overall- 85.75 slightly above average, could have used more depth and complexity
Thursday, November 26, 2009
Partagas Lusitania (Box Date 2001?)
I am not sure about the box date on this one, but the belief is that it comes from a 2001 box. The cigar is breathtaking to behold. Big, firm and leathery this cigar has not a single visual flaw anywhere on the wrapper. The wrapper is oily, the construction is tight and the only problem is that the foot has frayed a bit. The pre light aroma is of spice and cedar. The pre light draw is of clove and raisin.
The cigar begins with a subtle, yet complex profile, of clove, spice and raisin. At the back of the palate there is a fine dusting of leathery flavor that adds to the experience. The draw is a bit tight, but I expect that of Habanos. The burn is sharp and there is an approximately one eighth inch shoulder between the wrapper and ash. I settle in for a long smoke.
The first quarter of the cigar burns well, but continues to draw a bit tight. The profile has settled into a nice mix of leather, spice and clove. There are very satisfying notes of toasted wood and a cedary sweetness through the nose and at the back of the palate. The ash is a dirty gray, but is very firm, holding to nearly two inches.
At the halfway point the profile develops even further. There are core notes of leather, spice and cedar, but there are some vanilla notes as well that have added to the complexity of the smoke. Through the nose I am still experiencing some beautiful notes of toasted wood. The burn is still excellent and the ash is firm and strong.
The third quarter of the cigar maintains a core of leather and spice, but the vanilla flavors have become more prominent. The cedar notes and toasted wood continue to show through as well and this cigar is showing a lot of cat and mouse subtlety for such a large vitola. Most people typically expect a big cigar to be in your face. The come hither disposition of this cigar is a surprise, and a pleasant one. The draw is still a touch tight and it causing some heat in the smoke.
The final quarter of the cigar really hits home. The profile becomes a final rush of powerful leathery and cedar notes. There is still some sweetness at the back of the palate, but the core leathery flavor dominates.
The finish is long and smooth. It holds a profile of leather and cedar for many minutes. I smoked this over a two and three quarter hour period and I can say I would have gladly spent double that time smoking a cigar of this quality.
Appearance- 97 one of the finest looking cigars I have seen
Taste- 96 an excellent profile that was very complex, some of the flavors could have used some more depth
Construction- 88 the tight draw and the resulting heat cause a reduction here
Strength- 92 a medium/full offering that compliments the profile well, but could have shown more power
Overall- 93.25 a fabulous smoke of very high quality, without the draw issues it would have been classic
The cigar begins with a subtle, yet complex profile, of clove, spice and raisin. At the back of the palate there is a fine dusting of leathery flavor that adds to the experience. The draw is a bit tight, but I expect that of Habanos. The burn is sharp and there is an approximately one eighth inch shoulder between the wrapper and ash. I settle in for a long smoke.
The first quarter of the cigar burns well, but continues to draw a bit tight. The profile has settled into a nice mix of leather, spice and clove. There are very satisfying notes of toasted wood and a cedary sweetness through the nose and at the back of the palate. The ash is a dirty gray, but is very firm, holding to nearly two inches.
At the halfway point the profile develops even further. There are core notes of leather, spice and cedar, but there are some vanilla notes as well that have added to the complexity of the smoke. Through the nose I am still experiencing some beautiful notes of toasted wood. The burn is still excellent and the ash is firm and strong.
The third quarter of the cigar maintains a core of leather and spice, but the vanilla flavors have become more prominent. The cedar notes and toasted wood continue to show through as well and this cigar is showing a lot of cat and mouse subtlety for such a large vitola. Most people typically expect a big cigar to be in your face. The come hither disposition of this cigar is a surprise, and a pleasant one. The draw is still a touch tight and it causing some heat in the smoke.
The final quarter of the cigar really hits home. The profile becomes a final rush of powerful leathery and cedar notes. There is still some sweetness at the back of the palate, but the core leathery flavor dominates.
The finish is long and smooth. It holds a profile of leather and cedar for many minutes. I smoked this over a two and three quarter hour period and I can say I would have gladly spent double that time smoking a cigar of this quality.
Appearance- 97 one of the finest looking cigars I have seen
Taste- 96 an excellent profile that was very complex, some of the flavors could have used some more depth
Construction- 88 the tight draw and the resulting heat cause a reduction here
Strength- 92 a medium/full offering that compliments the profile well, but could have shown more power
Overall- 93.25 a fabulous smoke of very high quality, without the draw issues it would have been classic
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
Illusione Epernay
This is a newer cigar from the excellent Illusione line of smokes. I have not reviewed any of these here, but I have always found them to be excellent. This cigar presents with a beautiful wrapper, the shade of lightly creamed coffee. There are minimal veins and the wrapper has a silky texture. The cigar seems a bit soft to me, but I decide that there will probably not be any issues. The pre light aroma shows notes of coffee, cocoa and dark fruit. The pre light draw smacks of coffee and nutmeg.
The cigar opens with a breathtaking profile of sweet cream, coffee, nutmeg and some vanilla. The complexity of this cigar is outstanding from the start and the flavors are well developed and superior. The draw is loose, but not so much so that heat is an issue. The burn is sharp and the ash is solid and white.
The first third of the cigar shows a deep, complex profile of cream, coffee and vanilla. I am stunned by this cigar at this point and I am slowing down so as not to plow through and miss what this cigar is telling me. The draw continues to luxuriate my palate with thick masses of smoke that boom out and hang satisfactorily around my head. The burn is still sharp and the ash is a nice bright white.
The next third of the cigar continues to impress, there is so much going on in this smoke it is hard to figure out what it all means. The profile shows rich coffee notes, cream and vanilla. At the back of the palate I am picking up satisfying notes of nutmeg and clean tobacco flavors. The draw and burn continue to show favorably to this point.
The final third of the cigar is simply stunning. The profile has notes of toast, coffee, sweet cream, nutmeg and toffee. At the back of the palate there is a sweetness that has the flavor of caramel. The burn and draw continue to be excellent.
The finish is long and smooth and shows notes of coffee and caramel with beautiful undertones of toasty bread. This is a definitely a winner and one of the finest cigars I have smoked in recent memory.
Appearance- 94 visually stunning
Taste- 97 a fabulous taste experience
Construction- 91 the loose draw hurt the cigar at the end, but still excellent
Strength- 96 a wonderful medium that compliments the profile unlike any other cigar I have smoked
Overall- 94.5 an absolutely fantastic cigar experience that should not be missed
The cigar opens with a breathtaking profile of sweet cream, coffee, nutmeg and some vanilla. The complexity of this cigar is outstanding from the start and the flavors are well developed and superior. The draw is loose, but not so much so that heat is an issue. The burn is sharp and the ash is solid and white.
The first third of the cigar shows a deep, complex profile of cream, coffee and vanilla. I am stunned by this cigar at this point and I am slowing down so as not to plow through and miss what this cigar is telling me. The draw continues to luxuriate my palate with thick masses of smoke that boom out and hang satisfactorily around my head. The burn is still sharp and the ash is a nice bright white.
The next third of the cigar continues to impress, there is so much going on in this smoke it is hard to figure out what it all means. The profile shows rich coffee notes, cream and vanilla. At the back of the palate I am picking up satisfying notes of nutmeg and clean tobacco flavors. The draw and burn continue to show favorably to this point.
The final third of the cigar is simply stunning. The profile has notes of toast, coffee, sweet cream, nutmeg and toffee. At the back of the palate there is a sweetness that has the flavor of caramel. The burn and draw continue to be excellent.
The finish is long and smooth and shows notes of coffee and caramel with beautiful undertones of toasty bread. This is a definitely a winner and one of the finest cigars I have smoked in recent memory.
Appearance- 94 visually stunning
Taste- 97 a fabulous taste experience
Construction- 91 the loose draw hurt the cigar at the end, but still excellent
Strength- 96 a wonderful medium that compliments the profile unlike any other cigar I have smoked
Overall- 94.5 an absolutely fantastic cigar experience that should not be missed
Arturo Fuente Chateau Sungrown
This is another old standby, and was a standard cigar in my lineup for years. The cigar presents in a cedar sleeve with the famous black satin band at the foot. The cigar itself has some prominent veins and the construction feels a bit firm. The pre light aroma is of earth and spice. The pre light draw shows notes of spice, earth and some grass.
The cigar begins with a spicy profile that shows notes of pepper and earth. There is a clean tobacco flavor that I have always noticed in this cigar, and this one is no exception. The draw is a bit tight, making the smoke thin. The burn is somewhat lopsided, but a crisp white ash is forming. There are some grassy flavors at the back of the palate and through the nose, which is disturbing.
The first half of the cigar shows plenty of spice and pepper, but the continuation of grassy flavors detracts from the smoke. The draw opens slightly and the production of smoke is satisfactory. The burn is still slightly akimbo, but the white ash is firm.
The last half of the cigar continues with a profile of spice and pepper, but the grassy notes persist and detract from the experience. The draw and burn have both improved and show no defects. There is some sweet earthiness at the back of the palate that helps offset some of the grassy effects.
The finish is troubling and shows a melange of spice, earth, pepper and grassy notes.
Appearance- 87 some veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 grassy flavors throughout detract from the score
Construction- 86 early draw issues limit the possibilities here
Strength- 87 a nice medium/smoke
Overall- 86 a slightly above average smoke
The cigar begins with a spicy profile that shows notes of pepper and earth. There is a clean tobacco flavor that I have always noticed in this cigar, and this one is no exception. The draw is a bit tight, making the smoke thin. The burn is somewhat lopsided, but a crisp white ash is forming. There are some grassy flavors at the back of the palate and through the nose, which is disturbing.
The first half of the cigar shows plenty of spice and pepper, but the continuation of grassy flavors detracts from the smoke. The draw opens slightly and the production of smoke is satisfactory. The burn is still slightly akimbo, but the white ash is firm.
The last half of the cigar continues with a profile of spice and pepper, but the grassy notes persist and detract from the experience. The draw and burn have both improved and show no defects. There is some sweet earthiness at the back of the palate that helps offset some of the grassy effects.
The finish is troubling and shows a melange of spice, earth, pepper and grassy notes.
Appearance- 87 some veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 grassy flavors throughout detract from the score
Construction- 86 early draw issues limit the possibilities here
Strength- 87 a nice medium/smoke
Overall- 86 a slightly above average smoke
Saturday, November 21, 2009
Jose Seijas Robusto
This is a very high end smoke from the master blender at Tabacalera Garcia. It presents with a very dark and toothy wrapper that appears to be expertly applied. There is some veining, but an inspection of the cigar leads me to believe that it is well made. The pre light aroma has notes of earth and rich wood, there is a nice tobacco essence to the nose. The pre light draw shows some bitter notes, but has some nice tobacco and earth flavor.
The cigar begins with a core profile of rich tobacco and dark wood flavors, there is a slightly charred overtone at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent and produces ample smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is flaky, but it has a nice crisp white color.
The first third of the cigar shows little development. There are notes of wood, tobacco and earth, but the charred bitterness persists and is hurting the experience. The burn has evened out and the draw is exceptional.
At the halfway point the profile has picked up some more flavors of rich wood and strong coffee, but there is still bitterness that is distracting and hinging on unpleasant. The burn and draw have stayed strong and aside from the flaky ash the cigar is performing well.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of strong coffee and rich wood. There is still a charred, bitter overtone to the flavors. The burn and draw have continued to perform well.
The finish is middling, with notes of coffee, wood and charred paper.
Appearance- 87 veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 the charred notes hurt the under developed profile that needed more complexity and depth
Construction- 93 a very well made cigar that performed well
Strength- 85 an unremarkable full that could have complimented the profile in a better way
Overall- 87.25 not bad, but not good for the price tag
The cigar begins with a core profile of rich tobacco and dark wood flavors, there is a slightly charred overtone at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent and produces ample smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided and the ash is flaky, but it has a nice crisp white color.
The first third of the cigar shows little development. There are notes of wood, tobacco and earth, but the charred bitterness persists and is hurting the experience. The burn has evened out and the draw is exceptional.
At the halfway point the profile has picked up some more flavors of rich wood and strong coffee, but there is still bitterness that is distracting and hinging on unpleasant. The burn and draw have stayed strong and aside from the flaky ash the cigar is performing well.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of strong coffee and rich wood. There is still a charred, bitter overtone to the flavors. The burn and draw have continued to perform well.
The finish is middling, with notes of coffee, wood and charred paper.
Appearance- 87 veining hurts the score
Taste- 84 the charred notes hurt the under developed profile that needed more complexity and depth
Construction- 93 a very well made cigar that performed well
Strength- 85 an unremarkable full that could have complimented the profile in a better way
Overall- 87.25 not bad, but not good for the price tag
Friday, November 20, 2009
Hoyo de Monterrey Dark Sumatra Noche
This is a cigar that I am revisiting after a long period of not smoking this particular vintage. The cigar presents well with a very dark wrapper cloaked in a cedar wrap. The cigar is toothy and has some prominent veins. The pre light aroma is earthy, with hints of chocolate and coffee. The pre light draw is sharp and bitter with notes of burnt coffee.
The cigar begins with a core profile of charred wood and burning coffee. There is some distinct bitterness at the back of the palate. The draw is thin, but produces enough smoke to be acceptable. The burn is even and a nice white ash forms crisply.
The first third of the cigar is not pleasant. It is bitter, acrid and charred with some notes of chocolate, earth and coffee all muddled by bitterness. The draw is still acceptable, but a but thin. The burn shows some signs of going off track, but to this point is acceptable.
At the halfway point it is all I can do to keep going. The profile is still bitter and charred. There are some notes of earth and coffee, but they are masked by the harsh bitter tones. The burn has stayed slightly off kilter, but it is still acceptable. The draw is opening a little bit, but I wish it would get tighter to spare me the mouthfuls of putrescence.
The final half of the cigar is a complete write off. The profile is almost completely gone, all that is left is charred and bitter flotsam that offends the palate at every turn. Unfortunately the draw opens further, releasing an entirely new vintage of awfulness. The burn is still OK, but it is a fleeting silver lining on an otherwise dark cloud.
The finish is terrible and smacks of burned wood and other harsh bitter notes. This is an experience that makes me wonder why anyone would ever bother with this cigar. I also wonder why it is still on the market.
Appearance- 85 the veining hurts the score
Taste- 70 the lowest possible score for a truly bottom of the barrel experience
Construction- 80 early draw issues hurt the score
Strength- 70 impossible to give and other score due to the bitter and acrid profile
Overall- 76.25 a true waste of an hour and a half
The cigar begins with a core profile of charred wood and burning coffee. There is some distinct bitterness at the back of the palate. The draw is thin, but produces enough smoke to be acceptable. The burn is even and a nice white ash forms crisply.
The first third of the cigar is not pleasant. It is bitter, acrid and charred with some notes of chocolate, earth and coffee all muddled by bitterness. The draw is still acceptable, but a but thin. The burn shows some signs of going off track, but to this point is acceptable.
At the halfway point it is all I can do to keep going. The profile is still bitter and charred. There are some notes of earth and coffee, but they are masked by the harsh bitter tones. The burn has stayed slightly off kilter, but it is still acceptable. The draw is opening a little bit, but I wish it would get tighter to spare me the mouthfuls of putrescence.
The final half of the cigar is a complete write off. The profile is almost completely gone, all that is left is charred and bitter flotsam that offends the palate at every turn. Unfortunately the draw opens further, releasing an entirely new vintage of awfulness. The burn is still OK, but it is a fleeting silver lining on an otherwise dark cloud.
The finish is terrible and smacks of burned wood and other harsh bitter notes. This is an experience that makes me wonder why anyone would ever bother with this cigar. I also wonder why it is still on the market.
Appearance- 85 the veining hurts the score
Taste- 70 the lowest possible score for a truly bottom of the barrel experience
Construction- 80 early draw issues hurt the score
Strength- 70 impossible to give and other score due to the bitter and acrid profile
Overall- 76.25 a true waste of an hour and a half
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
La Fontana Galileo
This is an offering from Camacho. It presents with a very light wrapper that is silky and flawless, with very few veins. The construction feels as if it might be a bit soft, but I can't tell if there will be issues with the performance. The pre light aroma is light and has hints of balsa and a sweet note of bread. The pre light draw is put off by the sweetened head of the cigar.
The cigar begins with a sweet profile that has notes of vanilla and toast. There is some light pepper and fruit at the back of the palate. The draw is exceptional and produces an excellent amount of smoke. The burn is even and produces a light gray ash that is a touch flaky.
At the one inch point the profile is very mellow and shows notes of vanilla and light wood flavors. The burn and draw are both consistent. At the back of the palate there are some sweet floral notes, but there is a thin grassy flavor there as well.
At the halfway point the cigar continues to show vanilla and wood notes, but there is a lack of complexity and depth. The burn is slightly off at this point and the ash continues to flake. The draw is still performing well and is easy and smooth.
The final half of the cigar performs well. The profile has a core of sweet floral notes, with slight touches of vanilla and cinnamon. The depth and complexity are still disappointing. The burn and draw continue to perform well throughout.
The finish is shallow and shows some sour notes that will hurt the score.
Appearance- 89 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 85 the complexity and depth were not there and sour notes on the finish hurt the score
Construction- 91 the cigar performed well, but the flaky ash was off putting
Strength- 88 a very mild smoke that could have used some more strength
Overall- 88.25 not a bad experience
The cigar begins with a sweet profile that has notes of vanilla and toast. There is some light pepper and fruit at the back of the palate. The draw is exceptional and produces an excellent amount of smoke. The burn is even and produces a light gray ash that is a touch flaky.
At the one inch point the profile is very mellow and shows notes of vanilla and light wood flavors. The burn and draw are both consistent. At the back of the palate there are some sweet floral notes, but there is a thin grassy flavor there as well.
At the halfway point the cigar continues to show vanilla and wood notes, but there is a lack of complexity and depth. The burn is slightly off at this point and the ash continues to flake. The draw is still performing well and is easy and smooth.
The final half of the cigar performs well. The profile has a core of sweet floral notes, with slight touches of vanilla and cinnamon. The depth and complexity are still disappointing. The burn and draw continue to perform well throughout.
The finish is shallow and shows some sour notes that will hurt the score.
Appearance- 89 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 85 the complexity and depth were not there and sour notes on the finish hurt the score
Construction- 91 the cigar performed well, but the flaky ash was off putting
Strength- 88 a very mild smoke that could have used some more strength
Overall- 88.25 not a bad experience
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Nova
This is the Tempus version of a robusto. The cigar presents well with a wrapper that has a reddish hue, almost like a Colorado capa. There is some veining, but nothing that detracts from the overall visual experience. I will make special mention of the exceptional band work on this smoke, it is stunning. The pre light aroma has hints of spice and dark fruit. The pre light draw showed some sweet notes, but has a nice taste of rich tobacco.
The cigar begins with an interesting profile of cherry and spice flavors. There is some pepper, and a strange floral essence at the middle and back of the palate. The draw on this cigar is superb, very easy and smooth and producing scads of smoke from the get go. The burn is a bit crooked, but there is a nice shoulder at the meeting of the wrapper and the ash.
At the two inch mark the core of the profile is of cedar, but there are still some notes of cherry and spice in the backdrop. There is still a strange sweetness to the smoke and I can't attribute it to one particular flavor. The draw is still excellent, but the burn is still showing some crooked angles.
At the halfway point the profile shows notes of pepper and dark wood, but there is a charred flavor that has entered the mix. There are still some sweet notes at the back of the palate. The draw and burn are consistent with earlier observations.
The final half of the smoke continues to show notes of pepper and wood, but the charred notes are strong. The draw stayed excellent, but the burn was lopsided throughout.
The finish was thin and charred. The profile lacked depth and complexity.
Appearance- 92 a very attractive cigar
Taste- 83 the charred notes hurt what would have been a pleasant profile
Construction- 92 an excellent performance
Strength- 84 a medium/full that could have used more power
Overall- 87.75 saved by construction and appearance
The cigar begins with an interesting profile of cherry and spice flavors. There is some pepper, and a strange floral essence at the middle and back of the palate. The draw on this cigar is superb, very easy and smooth and producing scads of smoke from the get go. The burn is a bit crooked, but there is a nice shoulder at the meeting of the wrapper and the ash.
At the two inch mark the core of the profile is of cedar, but there are still some notes of cherry and spice in the backdrop. There is still a strange sweetness to the smoke and I can't attribute it to one particular flavor. The draw is still excellent, but the burn is still showing some crooked angles.
At the halfway point the profile shows notes of pepper and dark wood, but there is a charred flavor that has entered the mix. There are still some sweet notes at the back of the palate. The draw and burn are consistent with earlier observations.
The final half of the smoke continues to show notes of pepper and wood, but the charred notes are strong. The draw stayed excellent, but the burn was lopsided throughout.
The finish was thin and charred. The profile lacked depth and complexity.
Appearance- 92 a very attractive cigar
Taste- 83 the charred notes hurt what would have been a pleasant profile
Construction- 92 an excellent performance
Strength- 84 a medium/full that could have used more power
Overall- 87.75 saved by construction and appearance
Montecristo White Corona
This is another mild smoke that I have enjoyed for years. The cigar presents with a beautiful wrapper in a blond shade that is the color of light sand. There is some veining that takes away from the appeal of the wrapper. The cigar feels silky and seems like it is tightly packed, but not too firm. The pre light aroma is of bread and graham cracker. The pre light draw has notes of cinnamon and light spice.
The cigar begins well, with a nice profile of cinnamon and some light pepper. At the back of the palate there is a floral sweetness that is a nice compliment. The draw is a touch on the tight side in the early stages. The burn is excellent and is producing a medium gray ash that is very crisp.
At the inch and a half mark the cigar takes on a smoother character. There are notes of ginger and light spice. At the back of the palate I detect some cinnamon flavors that are light and fleeting. The draw has opened up at this point and it allows for a more complete smoking experience. The burn is still sharp and the ash is firm.
At the halfway mark the cigar is still performing well. The core of the profile is of cinnamon with hints of ginger and spice. At the back of the palate a nice earthy sweetness has developed. The draw and burn continue to perform well at this point.
The final half of the cigar continues to show depth and complexity. The profile has notes of cinnamon, ginger, spice and light pepper. At the back of the palate there is a hint of sour note that detracts from the overall experience. The burn and draw have stayed nearly perfect in the back half of the cigar.
The finish is too short for me, but shows notes of cinnamon and spice. The sour note is still present and will hurt the score.
Appearance- 90 and excellent looking smoke
Taste- 88 the sour notes hurt this score, but the profile is otherwise excellent
Construction- 89 aside from the early tightness in the draw this was well above average
Strength- 93 an excellent mild that compliments the profile beautifully
Overall- 90 an excellent smoke that could have been better without the sour notes in the last half
The cigar begins well, with a nice profile of cinnamon and some light pepper. At the back of the palate there is a floral sweetness that is a nice compliment. The draw is a touch on the tight side in the early stages. The burn is excellent and is producing a medium gray ash that is very crisp.
At the inch and a half mark the cigar takes on a smoother character. There are notes of ginger and light spice. At the back of the palate I detect some cinnamon flavors that are light and fleeting. The draw has opened up at this point and it allows for a more complete smoking experience. The burn is still sharp and the ash is firm.
At the halfway mark the cigar is still performing well. The core of the profile is of cinnamon with hints of ginger and spice. At the back of the palate a nice earthy sweetness has developed. The draw and burn continue to perform well at this point.
The final half of the cigar continues to show depth and complexity. The profile has notes of cinnamon, ginger, spice and light pepper. At the back of the palate there is a hint of sour note that detracts from the overall experience. The burn and draw have stayed nearly perfect in the back half of the cigar.
The finish is too short for me, but shows notes of cinnamon and spice. The sour note is still present and will hurt the score.
Appearance- 90 and excellent looking smoke
Taste- 88 the sour notes hurt this score, but the profile is otherwise excellent
Construction- 89 aside from the early tightness in the draw this was well above average
Strength- 93 an excellent mild that compliments the profile beautifully
Overall- 90 an excellent smoke that could have been better without the sour notes in the last half
Monday, November 16, 2009
Cusano Cuvee Blanc Salomon
This is a gigantic cigar. Branch like in it's presentation, the cigar is dry and shows some cracking in what appears to be a thin wrapper. There are prominent veins, some of them actually remind me of a surgically sutured wound. The cigar is firm and appears to be tight. The pre light aroma is grassy and has an essence of hay in autumn. The pre light draw is thin and smacks of grass and dry chaff.
The cigar begins with notes of grass and vegetation, there is a slight sweetness at the back of the palate. The draw is acceptable, but does not produce a satisfying amount of smoke in the opening minutes. The burn is firm and a dirty gray ash is forming, all though it is a bit flaky. The first several inches of the cigar progress in the same manner.
At just before the halfway point the profile has notes of grass, dry cereal, cardboard and paper. There is still an odd sweetness at the back of the palate, but it is not lending any enjoyability to the smoke. The draw is opening up slightly and the burn has stayed consistent.
The final half of the cigar shows a profile of grass with papery notes that dominate the back of the palate. At the halfway point I was sensing that some good flavors might be forthcoming, I could not have been any more wrong about that supposition. The burn and draw have stay acceptable throughout the smoke.
The finish is thin with notes of grass, dry vegetation and paper.
Appearance- 80 not an attractive looking cigar at all, this size should be presented more spectacularly
Taste- 74 the profile lacks complexity, depth and anything resembling a flavor that anyone would want in a cigar
Construction- 86 the lack of smoke was a disappointment
Strength- 75 an unremarkable mild cigar that shows no compliment to the profile
Overall- 78.75 a really poor cigar that has few redeeming characteristics, I rejoiced when it was over
The cigar begins with notes of grass and vegetation, there is a slight sweetness at the back of the palate. The draw is acceptable, but does not produce a satisfying amount of smoke in the opening minutes. The burn is firm and a dirty gray ash is forming, all though it is a bit flaky. The first several inches of the cigar progress in the same manner.
At just before the halfway point the profile has notes of grass, dry cereal, cardboard and paper. There is still an odd sweetness at the back of the palate, but it is not lending any enjoyability to the smoke. The draw is opening up slightly and the burn has stayed consistent.
The final half of the cigar shows a profile of grass with papery notes that dominate the back of the palate. At the halfway point I was sensing that some good flavors might be forthcoming, I could not have been any more wrong about that supposition. The burn and draw have stay acceptable throughout the smoke.
The finish is thin with notes of grass, dry vegetation and paper.
Appearance- 80 not an attractive looking cigar at all, this size should be presented more spectacularly
Taste- 74 the profile lacks complexity, depth and anything resembling a flavor that anyone would want in a cigar
Construction- 86 the lack of smoke was a disappointment
Strength- 75 an unremarkable mild cigar that shows no compliment to the profile
Overall- 78.75 a really poor cigar that has few redeeming characteristics, I rejoiced when it was over
Friday, November 13, 2009
Ashton Classic Corona
This is, as the name implies, a classic cigar. I have smoked these for years and always found them to be smooth, mild and enjoyable. The cigar presents well with a near blond wrapper that is smooth with a dusty texture. There is a minor flaw that detracts from the overall presentation, but the cigar appears to be well made. An inspection reveals some firm spots and I have some concern about what that will do to the draw. The pre light aroma is full of cedary notes with a hint of cinnamon. The pre light draw is tight, but it shows sweet floral notes.
The cigar opens smoothly with a profile of cedar, cream and sweet floral notes. The draw is a tight, but I am not laboring to produce appropriate amounts of smoke. The burn is strong and the ash is a solid gray.
At the one inch point the profile smooths out even more, taking on a core profile of cedar with some floral essence. There are some nutmeg and cinnamon notes through the nose. The draw is loosening up some and the smoke is heavy and satisfactory. The burn is still very sharp and the ash remains solid.
At the halfway point the cigar continues with a profile of cedar with some floral undertones. At the back of the palate there are some bready notes and still some hints of cinnamon. The draw is still tight, but continues to open up as the smoke progresses.
The final half of the cigar continues to show a deep core of cedar notes, there are still hints of cinnamon and bread at the back of the palate. The cigar lacks some complexity, but has plenty of depth and rich flavor. The draw and burn have maintained the same characteristics throughout the smoke.
The finish is smooth and shows notes of cedar, bread and a little bit of white pepper.
Appearance- 87 an excellent looking cigar, a blemish hurt the score
Taste- 90 an excellent profile with deep flavor, I would like more complexity
Construction- 86 the tightness in the draw hurts the score
Strength- 93 a fabulous mild that compliments the profile expertly
Overall- 89 an excellent smoke
The cigar opens smoothly with a profile of cedar, cream and sweet floral notes. The draw is a tight, but I am not laboring to produce appropriate amounts of smoke. The burn is strong and the ash is a solid gray.
At the one inch point the profile smooths out even more, taking on a core profile of cedar with some floral essence. There are some nutmeg and cinnamon notes through the nose. The draw is loosening up some and the smoke is heavy and satisfactory. The burn is still very sharp and the ash remains solid.
At the halfway point the cigar continues with a profile of cedar with some floral undertones. At the back of the palate there are some bready notes and still some hints of cinnamon. The draw is still tight, but continues to open up as the smoke progresses.
The final half of the cigar continues to show a deep core of cedar notes, there are still hints of cinnamon and bread at the back of the palate. The cigar lacks some complexity, but has plenty of depth and rich flavor. The draw and burn have maintained the same characteristics throughout the smoke.
The finish is smooth and shows notes of cedar, bread and a little bit of white pepper.
Appearance- 87 an excellent looking cigar, a blemish hurt the score
Taste- 90 an excellent profile with deep flavor, I would like more complexity
Construction- 86 the tightness in the draw hurts the score
Strength- 93 a fabulous mild that compliments the profile expertly
Overall- 89 an excellent smoke
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Cuesta Rey Centro Fino Sungrown Robusto
This is another cigar that I have smoked for years, but that I have not had in some time. The cigar presents in a more traditional robusto size, a vitola that many makers have eschewed for a larger ring gauge and added length in recent years. The wrapper is a medium brown with some serious tooth. There are few veins and the wrapper is nicely applied. The pre light aroma has a barnyard essence, but there are some hints of spice and cedar. The pre light draw shows a nice light tobacco note.
The cigar begins with a profile that has some bitter notes that are metallic. There are some notes of spice and cedar, but they are muddled. The draw is acceptable and the burn has developed well.
In the first inch or so the bitterness subsides and the profile takes on a character of light spice with some sharp tobacco flavors. There is also an undertone of oak and nuts at the back of the palate. The burn and draw continue to perform well into the first half of the cigar.
At the halfway point the profile shows some development with notes of roasted nuts, spice and tobacco. There has been a return of some bitterness at the back of the palate and through the nose. The burn and draw are still showing well.
In the final half the profile shows notes of spice and oak, there is still some bitterness at the back of the palate that is detracting from the experience. The burn and draw have continued to perform well.
The finish is average with notes of spice and wood, but there are some papery/cardboard notes that hurt the final stages.
Appearance- 87 a nice looking smoke
Taste- 81 not very deep or complex, bitter notes hurt the score
Construction- 91 the cigar performs very well
Strength- 84 an unremarkable medium
Overall- 85.75 slightly above average
The cigar begins with a profile that has some bitter notes that are metallic. There are some notes of spice and cedar, but they are muddled. The draw is acceptable and the burn has developed well.
In the first inch or so the bitterness subsides and the profile takes on a character of light spice with some sharp tobacco flavors. There is also an undertone of oak and nuts at the back of the palate. The burn and draw continue to perform well into the first half of the cigar.
At the halfway point the profile shows some development with notes of roasted nuts, spice and tobacco. There has been a return of some bitterness at the back of the palate and through the nose. The burn and draw are still showing well.
In the final half the profile shows notes of spice and oak, there is still some bitterness at the back of the palate that is detracting from the experience. The burn and draw have continued to perform well.
The finish is average with notes of spice and wood, but there are some papery/cardboard notes that hurt the final stages.
Appearance- 87 a nice looking smoke
Taste- 81 not very deep or complex, bitter notes hurt the score
Construction- 91 the cigar performs very well
Strength- 84 an unremarkable medium
Overall- 85.75 slightly above average
Wednesday, November 11, 2009
Rocky Patel 1961 Robusto
This is a new blend from Rocky and I have been waiting to give one a go. The cigar presents with an oily sheen, and the wrapper has a nearly Colorado hue to it. There is one very prominent vein that runs the length of the smoke. The construction appears to be satisfactory and I do not detect any issues after an inspection. The pre light aroma has strong notes of spice with undertones of dark fruit. The pre light draw has a chemical flavor, but also shows notes of pepper and spice.
The cigar opens with a very tight draw, but I still do not feel anything in the cigar that would cause this issue. The profile has an interesting sweetness, but it is cloyed by a chemical flavor that is prominent. The burn has started out strong, but the labor to create smoke is disappointing.
The first third of the cigar shows some notes of spice, and sweetness. The chemical flavor has given way to a clean tobacco note that is interesting and very unique to this cigar. The draw loosens somewhat, but is still labor intensive. The burn has stayed sharp and is producing a nice clean, gray ash.
The second third of the cigar continues to show notes of spice, but the sweetness has taken on an herbal character. There are also some notes of light pepper and light wood at the back of the palate. The draw is still tight and is causing some undue heat to appear in the smoke. The burn has stayed crisp and the ash is well developed.
The final third shows some notes of vanilla and bread, but the chemical flavor has appeared again and is detracting from the overall experience. The draw is still too tight for me, but the heat is not hurting the smoke, there are no charred notes or feelings of discomfort. The burn is still excellent.
The finish has some bitter notes, and the chemical taste is still present. However, there are some pleasing notes of spice, roasted nuts and herbal sweetness.
Appearance- 86 the prominent vein detracts from the score
Taste- 82 due to the chemical notes a higher score is not possible, but the rest of the profile was pleasing
Construction- 78 the constant draw problems will not afford a higher score
Strength- 88 an enjoyable medium offering
Overall- 83.5 this could have been much better
The cigar opens with a very tight draw, but I still do not feel anything in the cigar that would cause this issue. The profile has an interesting sweetness, but it is cloyed by a chemical flavor that is prominent. The burn has started out strong, but the labor to create smoke is disappointing.
The first third of the cigar shows some notes of spice, and sweetness. The chemical flavor has given way to a clean tobacco note that is interesting and very unique to this cigar. The draw loosens somewhat, but is still labor intensive. The burn has stayed sharp and is producing a nice clean, gray ash.
The second third of the cigar continues to show notes of spice, but the sweetness has taken on an herbal character. There are also some notes of light pepper and light wood at the back of the palate. The draw is still tight and is causing some undue heat to appear in the smoke. The burn has stayed crisp and the ash is well developed.
The final third shows some notes of vanilla and bread, but the chemical flavor has appeared again and is detracting from the overall experience. The draw is still too tight for me, but the heat is not hurting the smoke, there are no charred notes or feelings of discomfort. The burn is still excellent.
The finish has some bitter notes, and the chemical taste is still present. However, there are some pleasing notes of spice, roasted nuts and herbal sweetness.
Appearance- 86 the prominent vein detracts from the score
Taste- 82 due to the chemical notes a higher score is not possible, but the rest of the profile was pleasing
Construction- 78 the constant draw problems will not afford a higher score
Strength- 88 an enjoyable medium offering
Overall- 83.5 this could have been much better
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Arturo Fuente Petit Corona Natural
This is an old standby in my cigar rotation, but one that I have not smoked in over a year. The cigar presents with a tawny wrapper that is showing some tooth. The construction appears to be excellent as the cigar is well packed, but alluringly supple. The cap is a bit awkward and the foot is slightly squared giving this cigar a look that is rustic in it's simplicity. The pre light aroma is a bit sour, but has toasty notes. The pre light draw shows notes of light wood.
The cigar begins with some bitterness in a core of woody, toasty notes. There is a creamy undertone that could be more nuanced without the bitter overtones. The draw is excellent, which is rare in cigars of this size. The burn is solid, if a bit lopsided, and produces a nice firm, gray ash.
At the halfway point the cigar has progressed nicely showing notes of light wood, nutmeg, light spice and some pepper. The complexity is surprising, but the depth of the flavors is disappointing. I like to have deep rich flavors to consider, this cigar has many flavors but they are often too fleeting to be properly evaluated. The draw is still excellent, and the burn is very solid, holding an ash to almost the halfway point.
The final half of the cigar continues to show complex notes of flavor. There are notes of nutmeg, spice, light wood and bread. The draw has continued to perform well and the burn has remained solid.
The finish is long and has pleasing bready and toasty qualities. This cigar has proven why old standbys have their place in every aficionado's humidor.
Appearance- 85 not the most attractive of smokes
Taste- 91 an excellent profile that loses points for early bitterness and lack of depth throughout
Construction- 95 an extremely well made cigar that performed flawlessly
Strength- 88 an excellent mild/medium offering that could use more oomph
Overall- 89.75 an exceptional small smoke that is approaching magnificence
The cigar begins with some bitterness in a core of woody, toasty notes. There is a creamy undertone that could be more nuanced without the bitter overtones. The draw is excellent, which is rare in cigars of this size. The burn is solid, if a bit lopsided, and produces a nice firm, gray ash.
At the halfway point the cigar has progressed nicely showing notes of light wood, nutmeg, light spice and some pepper. The complexity is surprising, but the depth of the flavors is disappointing. I like to have deep rich flavors to consider, this cigar has many flavors but they are often too fleeting to be properly evaluated. The draw is still excellent, and the burn is very solid, holding an ash to almost the halfway point.
The final half of the cigar continues to show complex notes of flavor. There are notes of nutmeg, spice, light wood and bread. The draw has continued to perform well and the burn has remained solid.
The finish is long and has pleasing bready and toasty qualities. This cigar has proven why old standbys have their place in every aficionado's humidor.
Appearance- 85 not the most attractive of smokes
Taste- 91 an excellent profile that loses points for early bitterness and lack of depth throughout
Construction- 95 an extremely well made cigar that performed flawlessly
Strength- 88 an excellent mild/medium offering that could use more oomph
Overall- 89.75 an exceptional small smoke that is approaching magnificence
Monday, November 9, 2009
El Tiante 23 Maduro Robusto
This is the cigar made by Major League Baseball legend Luis Tiante. The presentation is fun, coming in a red box with his uniform number and his signature. The cigar band has an illustration of a pitcher in a windup, I assume it is a caricature of Tiante, as his delivery was unique. The cigar presents well with a toothy, dark maduro wrapper that has little to no veining. The construction appears to be a little weak as I detect some areas that may be under filled. The pre light aroma is loamy and earthy, with hints of grass. The pre light draw shows grassy, earthy notes.
The cigar begins with a profile of earth, lightly toasted wheat and grass. The draw is very loose and is producing an almost overwhelming amount of smoke. The burn is sharp, and is producing a nice solid, white ash.
At the halfway point the profile is showing notes of wheat, earth, coffee and grass. The draw is still considerably loose and there is some heat entering the smoke. The burn is still acceptable, but there were some small runs in the first half of the smoke.
The final half of the cigar shows a profile of earth, coffee and grass. The draw has caused some undue heat in the last two inches of the smoke. The burn has continued to show minor flaws, but overall is above average.
The finish is short and shows some bitter notes. There are some grassy flavors, but there are some notes of coffee and earth.
Appearance- 91 a fun cigar
Taste- 83 too many grassy notes in the profile to score any higher
Construction- 85 the loose draw caused issues
Strength- 87 a nice medium/full presentation
Overall- 86.5 slightly above average
The cigar begins with a profile of earth, lightly toasted wheat and grass. The draw is very loose and is producing an almost overwhelming amount of smoke. The burn is sharp, and is producing a nice solid, white ash.
At the halfway point the profile is showing notes of wheat, earth, coffee and grass. The draw is still considerably loose and there is some heat entering the smoke. The burn is still acceptable, but there were some small runs in the first half of the smoke.
The final half of the cigar shows a profile of earth, coffee and grass. The draw has caused some undue heat in the last two inches of the smoke. The burn has continued to show minor flaws, but overall is above average.
The finish is short and shows some bitter notes. There are some grassy flavors, but there are some notes of coffee and earth.
Appearance- 91 a fun cigar
Taste- 83 too many grassy notes in the profile to score any higher
Construction- 85 the loose draw caused issues
Strength- 87 a nice medium/full presentation
Overall- 86.5 slightly above average
Avo Companero
This is a limited edition cigar for 2009. The cigar is something to behold in a vitola that is large and bulky, yet somehow still elegant. The wrapper is a rich, dark brown shade and has a nice oily sheen, there are some prominent veins. The construction appears to be excellent, I do not detect any spots that are too firm, or areas that indicate that the cigar might be underfilled. The pre light aroma has hints of spice, leather and grass. The pre light draw shows some peppery notes, but there is a grassy undertone.
The cigar opens well, with some notes of spice and tobacco. There is a grassy undertone that detracts from the opening experience. The burn is razor sharp and the ash is a very crisp white. The draw is slightly tight, but there is not an undue amount of labor required to produce acceptable amounts of smoke. For the first inch to inch and a half the grassy notes are the only detractors from this cigar.
At near the one third point of the cigar the profile has notes of spice, tobacco and a sweet herbal note. The grassy notes are still noticable at the back of the palate, but are fading away. The burn has stayed strong, but there is some flaking of the ash that causes a bit of a mess. The draw has opened up and is producing clouds of flavorful smoke.
At just past halfway the profile is showing notes of leather, rich tobacco and dark wood flavors. There is still an herbal tone at the back of the palate that is threatening to become grassy again. The burn and draw have stayed consistent.
The final half of the smoke shows a profile of leather, tobacco and grassy notes. The burn and draw stay true throughout the smoke showing excellent construction.
The finish is a bit sharp, showing notes of grass, tobacco and leather.
Appearance- 90 this is a very nicely presented cigar
Taste- 86 this would have been much higher without the grassy notes that pester the palate
Construction- 89 the tightness of the draw and flaky ash hurt this score
Strength- 91 a nice full presentation
Overall- 89 an excellent presentation that shows aging potential
The cigar opens well, with some notes of spice and tobacco. There is a grassy undertone that detracts from the opening experience. The burn is razor sharp and the ash is a very crisp white. The draw is slightly tight, but there is not an undue amount of labor required to produce acceptable amounts of smoke. For the first inch to inch and a half the grassy notes are the only detractors from this cigar.
At near the one third point of the cigar the profile has notes of spice, tobacco and a sweet herbal note. The grassy notes are still noticable at the back of the palate, but are fading away. The burn has stayed strong, but there is some flaking of the ash that causes a bit of a mess. The draw has opened up and is producing clouds of flavorful smoke.
At just past halfway the profile is showing notes of leather, rich tobacco and dark wood flavors. There is still an herbal tone at the back of the palate that is threatening to become grassy again. The burn and draw have stayed consistent.
The final half of the smoke shows a profile of leather, tobacco and grassy notes. The burn and draw stay true throughout the smoke showing excellent construction.
The finish is a bit sharp, showing notes of grass, tobacco and leather.
Appearance- 90 this is a very nicely presented cigar
Taste- 86 this would have been much higher without the grassy notes that pester the palate
Construction- 89 the tightness of the draw and flaky ash hurt this score
Strength- 91 a nice full presentation
Overall- 89 an excellent presentation that shows aging potential
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Joya de Nicaragua Fuerte Corona Gorda
This is a cigar that I had not smoked before. It presents with a dark, toothy wrapper that has prominent veins. The overall appearance is ruddy, the cigar is lopsided and has a sloppy cap. The construction appears to be a bit firm in spots, but I do not think there will be an issue. The pre light aroma has strong notes of anise and spice. The pre light draw shows a character of dark wood and spice.
The cigar opens with rich notes of dark wood and some light spice. The draw is excellent, producing thick smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided, but the ash is sturdy and has a light gray hue. There are some notes of coffee at the back of the palate as well.
At the halfway point the profile picks up some steam. There are notes of dark wood, anise, spice and coffee. The draw is still performing admirably and the burn has evened out a bit.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of wood, spice and coffee. The are some hints of toasted nuts at the back of the palate. The draw and burn have stayed consistent.
The finish is a bit short and a bitter note surfaces, but there are notes of wood and spice.
Appearance- 80 if you were judging this based on looks you would pass
Taste- 90 a surprisingly complex and deep profile
Construction- 88 a well made smoke
Strength- 87 a nice full smoke that could have been more complimentary to the profile
Overall- 86.25 hurt by appearance, but don't judge a book by it's cover...this is worth smoking
The cigar opens with rich notes of dark wood and some light spice. The draw is excellent, producing thick smoke. The burn is a bit lopsided, but the ash is sturdy and has a light gray hue. There are some notes of coffee at the back of the palate as well.
At the halfway point the profile picks up some steam. There are notes of dark wood, anise, spice and coffee. The draw is still performing admirably and the burn has evened out a bit.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of wood, spice and coffee. The are some hints of toasted nuts at the back of the palate. The draw and burn have stayed consistent.
The finish is a bit short and a bitter note surfaces, but there are notes of wood and spice.
Appearance- 80 if you were judging this based on looks you would pass
Taste- 90 a surprisingly complex and deep profile
Construction- 88 a well made smoke
Strength- 87 a nice full smoke that could have been more complimentary to the profile
Overall- 86.25 hurt by appearance, but don't judge a book by it's cover...this is worth smoking
Monday, November 2, 2009
Joya de Nicaragua Antano Robusto
This is a cigar I had not smoked in over a year. It presents in a chunky robusto vitola with a firm and hefty feel. The wrapper is dark and oily, there are some prominent veins around the entire shaft of the smoke. The pre light aroma is of tobacco and pepper. The pre light draw shows pepper and leaves the tingle of nicotine on the tongue.
The cigar opens with knockout intentions. The cigar is very strong and is numbing the palate with nicotine. The profile is of dark tobacco and pepper. There is a sour, nearly metallic note at the back of the palate that is detracting from the experience. The draw is a touch tight, but it is not causing any issues. The burn is sharp and the ash is very white and firm.
The first half of the cigar proceeds with a profile of tobacco and pepper that lacks depth and complexity, the sour note dissipates in the first inch or so. The draw opens up a bit as I smoke on, and the burn is still solid.
The final half of the cigar continues with a profile of tobacco and pepper, there is some development of a note of light spice and dark wood, but it is fleeting. The draw and the burn are acceptable.
The finish is a bit short and has some harshness that is unfortunate. There are notes of tobacco and dark wood on the back of the palate.
Appearance- 88 an attractive smoke, but veining hurts the appearance
Taste- 85 a very average profile, lacking in complexity and depth
Construction- 90 an extremely well made cigar that smoked beautifully
Strength- 83 a very full offering that overshadows the profile at points
Overall- 86.5 a slightly above average experience
The cigar opens with knockout intentions. The cigar is very strong and is numbing the palate with nicotine. The profile is of dark tobacco and pepper. There is a sour, nearly metallic note at the back of the palate that is detracting from the experience. The draw is a touch tight, but it is not causing any issues. The burn is sharp and the ash is very white and firm.
The first half of the cigar proceeds with a profile of tobacco and pepper that lacks depth and complexity, the sour note dissipates in the first inch or so. The draw opens up a bit as I smoke on, and the burn is still solid.
The final half of the cigar continues with a profile of tobacco and pepper, there is some development of a note of light spice and dark wood, but it is fleeting. The draw and the burn are acceptable.
The finish is a bit short and has some harshness that is unfortunate. There are notes of tobacco and dark wood on the back of the palate.
Appearance- 88 an attractive smoke, but veining hurts the appearance
Taste- 85 a very average profile, lacking in complexity and depth
Construction- 90 an extremely well made cigar that smoked beautifully
Strength- 83 a very full offering that overshadows the profile at points
Overall- 86.5 a slightly above average experience
Sunday, November 1, 2009
Quesada 35th Anniversary Serie Limitada
This cigar presents in a box pressed design in a vitola somewhere near a toro. The wrapper has a nice oily sheen, but there is some prominent veining that hurts the appearance. The pre light aroma has some notes of spice and dark fruit. The pre light draw shows some metallic notes, but has a nice peppery tone.
The cigar opens with blasts of pepper and some notes of spice. The draw is tight, but I have often found that to be the case with box pressed cigars. The burn is a touch lopsided, but it is not causing issues at this point.
The first third of the cigar continues to show notes of pepper and light spice, however there is a sour note at the back of the palate that is distracting. The draw is still tight, and the burn is showing signs of a canoe. I eventually have to relight before I can continue beyond the first third.
At the halfway point the profile has continued to deteriorate, there are notes of pepper and spice, but the sour flavors have moved further into the profile. The draw continues to tighten, and the burn is showing further signs of being erratic.
The final half of the cigar is nearly not smokeable. The profile is sour and metallic, with hints of coffee but there is not enough there to save the smoke. The burn has continued to canoe and I let the cigar go with a couple of inches left.
The finish is harsh and short.
Appearance- 86
Taste- 73 not a good profile
Construction- 72 the constant burn and draw problems killed the smoke
Strength- 88 a nice medium
Overall- 79.75 I expected more due to the premium price tag
The cigar opens with blasts of pepper and some notes of spice. The draw is tight, but I have often found that to be the case with box pressed cigars. The burn is a touch lopsided, but it is not causing issues at this point.
The first third of the cigar continues to show notes of pepper and light spice, however there is a sour note at the back of the palate that is distracting. The draw is still tight, and the burn is showing signs of a canoe. I eventually have to relight before I can continue beyond the first third.
At the halfway point the profile has continued to deteriorate, there are notes of pepper and spice, but the sour flavors have moved further into the profile. The draw continues to tighten, and the burn is showing further signs of being erratic.
The final half of the cigar is nearly not smokeable. The profile is sour and metallic, with hints of coffee but there is not enough there to save the smoke. The burn has continued to canoe and I let the cigar go with a couple of inches left.
The finish is harsh and short.
Appearance- 86
Taste- 73 not a good profile
Construction- 72 the constant burn and draw problems killed the smoke
Strength- 88 a nice medium
Overall- 79.75 I expected more due to the premium price tag
Saturday, October 31, 2009
Tatuaje Boris
This is a limited edition Halloween cigar from Pete Johnson and Don Pepin. It presents in a large vitola between a churchill and a presidente. The wrapper is dark and oily, there is some prominent veining but overall the appearance is interesting to behold. The cigar seems to be too soft, but there aren't any areas that cause me any concern. The pre light aroma is of tobacco, spice and dark fruit. The pre light draw shows notes of spice and earth.
The cigar begins with some light pepper notes, but there is a metallic bite on the back of the palate in the opening stages. The draw is a bit loose, but it is not overwhelming. The burn starts slightly lopsided, but evens about an inch into the cigar. The profile develops quickly with notes of coffee, spice and pepper.
At one third of the way into the cigar I am detecting a profile of coffee, spice and pepper. There is still a slightly metallic note at the back of the palate, but it is lessening as the smoke progresses. The draw is still loose, but not causing any issues. The burn has leveled off and is forming a nice white ash.
Near the halfway point the core of the profile is coffee, but there are notes of cinnamon and clove on the palate as well. The draw remains loose and is beginning to produce some heat. The burn is solid, but the ash is a bit flaky.
The final half of the cigar is excellent. The core of the profile is of coffee, but there are notes of spice, cinnamon, vanilla and clove. The depth and complexity of the final half of the cigar is noteworthy. The draw is causing some excess heat and it is detracting from the experience. The burn has stayed strong.
The finish is smooth, with notes of spice and coffee.
Appearance- 90 a nice looking cigar, but veining hurts the look
Taste- 89 excellent in the last half, but metallic notes in the early stages hurt the score
Construction- 84 the loose draws caused too much heat
Strength- 91 a nice medium/full experience
Overall- 88.5 a nice smoke, hurt by construction issues
The cigar begins with some light pepper notes, but there is a metallic bite on the back of the palate in the opening stages. The draw is a bit loose, but it is not overwhelming. The burn starts slightly lopsided, but evens about an inch into the cigar. The profile develops quickly with notes of coffee, spice and pepper.
At one third of the way into the cigar I am detecting a profile of coffee, spice and pepper. There is still a slightly metallic note at the back of the palate, but it is lessening as the smoke progresses. The draw is still loose, but not causing any issues. The burn has leveled off and is forming a nice white ash.
Near the halfway point the core of the profile is coffee, but there are notes of cinnamon and clove on the palate as well. The draw remains loose and is beginning to produce some heat. The burn is solid, but the ash is a bit flaky.
The final half of the cigar is excellent. The core of the profile is of coffee, but there are notes of spice, cinnamon, vanilla and clove. The depth and complexity of the final half of the cigar is noteworthy. The draw is causing some excess heat and it is detracting from the experience. The burn has stayed strong.
The finish is smooth, with notes of spice and coffee.
Appearance- 90 a nice looking cigar, but veining hurts the look
Taste- 89 excellent in the last half, but metallic notes in the early stages hurt the score
Construction- 84 the loose draws caused too much heat
Strength- 91 a nice medium/full experience
Overall- 88.5 a nice smoke, hurt by construction issues
Friday, October 30, 2009
CAO La Traviata Radiante
This is a new offering from CAO, and is the first CAO cigar that I have reviewed for this blog. It presents well with a rich, oily wrapper that has little veining. There is some fraying at the foot, but it does not appear to be an issue. The construction is firm, but I do not detect anything that would lead me to believe that there will be a problem. The pre light aroma is slightly sour, but has compelling notes of coffee, pepper and dark fruit. The pre light draw is peppery.
The cigar opens with a profile that is peppery and full of nicotine, the is a slight sourness at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent and the burn has begun in razor sharp fashion with a nice gray ash, that appears to be heavy.
The first third of the cigar shows notes of coffee and pepper, the flavor depth is a bit shallow, but the overall profile is nice. The draw has loosened and the cigar produces copious amounts of smoke. The burn has stayed consistent, but is starting to show some lopsidedness.
At the halfway point the cigar has maintained a core of coffee and pepper, the flavor has added some depth and is showing some promise. The draw is still loose and I am detecting some heat in the draw, so I slow it down and sip the cigar like a fine scotch. In slowing down I discover some added nuance in the profile and detect notes of cocoa. The burn is starting to canoe a bit, but I am attempting to smoke through it.
The final third of the cigar shows a core of coffee and pepper, but earth and cocoa tones are laced into the profile at this point. The draw has stayed loose and even though I have slowed down considerable the draw is showing some heat. The canoe has not straightened out, but I am close to the end so I leave it to it's own devices.
The finish is average and shows notes of earth and tobacco flavors.
Appearance- 91 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 88 some sour notes in the open hurt the score
Construction- 82 the loose draw caused too much heat
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full smoke
Overall- 87.25 a nice effort
The cigar opens with a profile that is peppery and full of nicotine, the is a slight sourness at the back of the palate. The draw is excellent and the burn has begun in razor sharp fashion with a nice gray ash, that appears to be heavy.
The first third of the cigar shows notes of coffee and pepper, the flavor depth is a bit shallow, but the overall profile is nice. The draw has loosened and the cigar produces copious amounts of smoke. The burn has stayed consistent, but is starting to show some lopsidedness.
At the halfway point the cigar has maintained a core of coffee and pepper, the flavor has added some depth and is showing some promise. The draw is still loose and I am detecting some heat in the draw, so I slow it down and sip the cigar like a fine scotch. In slowing down I discover some added nuance in the profile and detect notes of cocoa. The burn is starting to canoe a bit, but I am attempting to smoke through it.
The final third of the cigar shows a core of coffee and pepper, but earth and cocoa tones are laced into the profile at this point. The draw has stayed loose and even though I have slowed down considerable the draw is showing some heat. The canoe has not straightened out, but I am close to the end so I leave it to it's own devices.
The finish is average and shows notes of earth and tobacco flavors.
Appearance- 91 a nice looking cigar
Taste- 88 some sour notes in the open hurt the score
Construction- 82 the loose draw caused too much heat
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full smoke
Overall- 87.25 a nice effort
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Alec Bradley Family Blend No.1
This cigar presents in a curious size between a robusto and a toro. It is finished with an interesting pigtail cap that is a bit stunted when compared to traditional pigtail finishes. The wrapper is a beautiful, rich looking leaf that has some veining, but nothing too prominent. The pre light aroma has notes of cedar and spice. The pre light draw is a bit thin, but shows some woody notes, most noticeably cedar.
The cigar begins with a solid profile of cedar and some light spice. There is some sweetness in the profile, but I can't assign a particular attribute to it. The draw is excellent and the burn is acceptable, developing a dirty gray ash.
At the one third point of the cigar the profile has maintained notes of cedar and some light spice, but there is a solid earthy undertone influencing the smoke at this point. The draw has stayed consistent and the burn continues to be solid, showing no issues.
To the halfway point I am disappointed by the lack of complexity and depth, but I like the flavors in the profile. At this point I am noticing some creamy vanilla notes, but the core of the profile is still of cedar, wood and spice. The draw and burn are still showing strength.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of vanilla, spice and cedar. I am still disappointed buy the lack of complexity and depth in the profile. The burn and draw have stayed solid throughout.
The finish is acceptable, showing notes of earth, wood and spice.
Appearance- 87 an attractive cigar, the weird pigtail hurts the score
Taste- 86 a solid profile, but lacking in complexity and depth
Construction- 92 a well made cigar that smoked impeccably
Strength- 88 a nice medium
Overall- 88.25 an above average smoke, that could be fantastic with more depth and complexity
The cigar begins with a solid profile of cedar and some light spice. There is some sweetness in the profile, but I can't assign a particular attribute to it. The draw is excellent and the burn is acceptable, developing a dirty gray ash.
At the one third point of the cigar the profile has maintained notes of cedar and some light spice, but there is a solid earthy undertone influencing the smoke at this point. The draw has stayed consistent and the burn continues to be solid, showing no issues.
To the halfway point I am disappointed by the lack of complexity and depth, but I like the flavors in the profile. At this point I am noticing some creamy vanilla notes, but the core of the profile is still of cedar, wood and spice. The draw and burn are still showing strength.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of vanilla, spice and cedar. I am still disappointed buy the lack of complexity and depth in the profile. The burn and draw have stayed solid throughout.
The finish is acceptable, showing notes of earth, wood and spice.
Appearance- 87 an attractive cigar, the weird pigtail hurts the score
Taste- 86 a solid profile, but lacking in complexity and depth
Construction- 92 a well made cigar that smoked impeccably
Strength- 88 a nice medium
Overall- 88.25 an above average smoke, that could be fantastic with more depth and complexity
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
Gurkha Triple Ligero Toro
This is a cigar that comes packaged in all kinds of flair. It has a cedar sheath, two elaborate bands and a black ring around the bottom. The wrapper is toothy and full of veins, an inspection of the cigar shows no firm or soft spots, but the foot has some damage. The pre light aroma has notes of earth and spice. The pre light draw is nondescript and gives no indication of a profile.
The cigar begins with a profile of tobacco and dark wood, there is a sourness at the back of the palate that is not pleasant. The draw is excellent and the burn is crisp, with a white ash. The first inch and a half proceeds in the same fashion as described.
At just before the halfway point an ugly runner has developed and it is threatening to be a full canoe. I smoke on and hope for the best. The profile has developed more tobacco character and still shows notes of dark wood, but the sourness has not dissipated. The draw is still acceptable, but the burn is continuing to run.
The final half of the cigar continues to run and forms into a full canoe with about one third of the cigar remaining. The wrapper also begins to unravel toward the end of the smoke, leading to some further issues. The smoke is hot, and the profile takes on a charred character. There are still notes of tobacco and earth, but the charring hurts the experience.
The finish is short and bitter.
Appearance- 87 a nicely packaged and well presented cigar
Taste- 73 a very sub par profile with sour, charred notes throughout
Construction- 71 a poor example
Strength- 82 a medium/full offering that was difficult to judge against a poor profile
Overall- 78.25 a very poor effort, a cigar I will not smoke again
The cigar begins with a profile of tobacco and dark wood, there is a sourness at the back of the palate that is not pleasant. The draw is excellent and the burn is crisp, with a white ash. The first inch and a half proceeds in the same fashion as described.
At just before the halfway point an ugly runner has developed and it is threatening to be a full canoe. I smoke on and hope for the best. The profile has developed more tobacco character and still shows notes of dark wood, but the sourness has not dissipated. The draw is still acceptable, but the burn is continuing to run.
The final half of the cigar continues to run and forms into a full canoe with about one third of the cigar remaining. The wrapper also begins to unravel toward the end of the smoke, leading to some further issues. The smoke is hot, and the profile takes on a charred character. There are still notes of tobacco and earth, but the charring hurts the experience.
The finish is short and bitter.
Appearance- 87 a nicely packaged and well presented cigar
Taste- 73 a very sub par profile with sour, charred notes throughout
Construction- 71 a poor example
Strength- 82 a medium/full offering that was difficult to judge against a poor profile
Overall- 78.25 a very poor effort, a cigar I will not smoke again
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Padron 2000
This is one rough looking cigar. It is bumpy, rough, dry and box pressed. The cigar actually looks a lot like a cheroot, and I am hoping it has not been dipped in some awful flavor. All kidding aside, an inspection of the cigar leads me to believe that it is well made (despite appearances) and will smoke acceptably. The pre light aroma is full of earth and coffee essence. The pre light draw shows notes of light pepper and heavy tones of earth.
The cigar opens with a profile of heavy, loamy earth notes that are accented by some light notes of coffee. The draw is a bit loose, but it is performing well to this point. The burn is a bit lopsided, but with the issues noted in the appearance I am not surprised by this development.
At the halfway point the profile is still strikingly earthy, there is a sweetness that has come into the picture at this point as well. I am also detecting some light coffee elements, as well as a light note of pepper. The draw is still too loose, but the burn has stayed slightly lopsided but without issues.
The final half of the smoke continues to show notes of earth and coffee, but there are also notes of pepper, cocoa and some sweet milky flavors. The draw has remained loose and the smoke gets hot prematurely. The burn has stayed consistent.
The finish is a bit short and had some bitter notes, but there was a nice core of earth and tobacco on the finish.
Appearance- 75 this is not an attractive cigar at all
Taste- 89 I enjoyed the profile and only took away points for bitterness on the finish and some lack of depth
Construction- 86 points off for loose draw
Strength- 87 a nice medium cigar
Overall- 84.25 a nice cigar that would have been better with a stronger finish
The cigar opens with a profile of heavy, loamy earth notes that are accented by some light notes of coffee. The draw is a bit loose, but it is performing well to this point. The burn is a bit lopsided, but with the issues noted in the appearance I am not surprised by this development.
At the halfway point the profile is still strikingly earthy, there is a sweetness that has come into the picture at this point as well. I am also detecting some light coffee elements, as well as a light note of pepper. The draw is still too loose, but the burn has stayed slightly lopsided but without issues.
The final half of the smoke continues to show notes of earth and coffee, but there are also notes of pepper, cocoa and some sweet milky flavors. The draw has remained loose and the smoke gets hot prematurely. The burn has stayed consistent.
The finish is a bit short and had some bitter notes, but there was a nice core of earth and tobacco on the finish.
Appearance- 75 this is not an attractive cigar at all
Taste- 89 I enjoyed the profile and only took away points for bitterness on the finish and some lack of depth
Construction- 86 points off for loose draw
Strength- 87 a nice medium cigar
Overall- 84.25 a nice cigar that would have been better with a stronger finish
Monday, October 26, 2009
Casa Fuente Corona Gorda
This is the elusive cigar available only in Las Vegas, I have only smoke one before and it was while I was there. This is the first, and probably last that I will smoke outside of Vegas. The cigar presents with a nice, silky smooth medium brown wrapper. The construction of the cigar appears to be excellent and I detect no serious issues. The pre light aroma is of cinnamon and light spice. The pre light draw shows notes of cinnamon and strong tobacco flavors.
The cigar begins with full tobacco notes with hints of spice. This is very reminiscent of Opus X cigars that I have smoked. The draw is near perfect and the burn is sharp. This core of flavor is very deep, but lacks some complexity at this point in the cigar.
At the two inch mark the profile has developed into very strong notes of tobacco and spice, there is a hint of leather in the mix as well. The draw and burn have stayed superb.
At the halfway mark the cigar is still showing strong tobacco and spice notes, the leather notes are thready and that is disappointing. Burn and draw have stayed consistent to this point. The development of the palate has been deep, but it still lacks some complexity.
The final half of the cigar continues to show nice strong tobacco notes and some diminishing leather undertones, but the complexity is still lacking. The draw and burn have stayed excellent throughout the smoke.
The finish is a touch thin, there are notes of tobacco and spice, but a grassy and metallic note hurt the final impression.
Appearance- 89 a very attractive cigar, with fascinating band work
Taste- 88 the profile was nice and deep, but lacked complexity and was hurt by the finish
Construction- 96 an extremely well made cigar with nary a single issue
Strength- 91 an excellent full smoke that complimented the profile well
Overall- 91 largely due to the construction score
The cigar begins with full tobacco notes with hints of spice. This is very reminiscent of Opus X cigars that I have smoked. The draw is near perfect and the burn is sharp. This core of flavor is very deep, but lacks some complexity at this point in the cigar.
At the two inch mark the profile has developed into very strong notes of tobacco and spice, there is a hint of leather in the mix as well. The draw and burn have stayed superb.
At the halfway mark the cigar is still showing strong tobacco and spice notes, the leather notes are thready and that is disappointing. Burn and draw have stayed consistent to this point. The development of the palate has been deep, but it still lacks some complexity.
The final half of the cigar continues to show nice strong tobacco notes and some diminishing leather undertones, but the complexity is still lacking. The draw and burn have stayed excellent throughout the smoke.
The finish is a touch thin, there are notes of tobacco and spice, but a grassy and metallic note hurt the final impression.
Appearance- 89 a very attractive cigar, with fascinating band work
Taste- 88 the profile was nice and deep, but lacked complexity and was hurt by the finish
Construction- 96 an extremely well made cigar with nary a single issue
Strength- 91 an excellent full smoke that complimented the profile well
Overall- 91 largely due to the construction score
Saturday, October 24, 2009
La Triunfador Lancero
This is a new offering from Pete Johnson and Don Pepin Garcia. The cigar has a ruddy appearance, with a low quality cigar band. There are prominent veins and the cigar has a bumpy exterior. The wrapper is dark and silky. The pre light aroma is mild with notes of sweet fruit and light tobacco. The pre light draw shows light spice and a sweet note.
The cigar begins with a sweet flavor that is difficult to name. There are some nice tobacco notes present and light spice that adds character. The burn is solid, but the draw is tight as expected from this vitola.
At the one quarter point the sweetness has developed well and is reminiscent of coconut. There are still some nice tobacco notes and some spice present as well. The burn is consistent and the draw is still tight.
At the halfway point the cigar has maintained a sweet core, there are still some fleeting tobacco notes. The burn is a bit lopsided, but there does not appear to be any issues on the horizon. The draw opens a little bit affording some more depth to the flavors.
The final half of the cigar proceeds much the same as the first. The sweet profile has maintained it's prominence, and there are notes of spice. The cigar has lacked depth and complexity.
The finish is acceptable with more sweet notes and some light spice.
Appearance- 83 not an attractive cigar
Taste- 86 some lack of depth and complexity hurt this score
Construction- 89 a well made cigar
Strength- 85 an unexpected medium/mild
Overall- 85.75 I expected more
The cigar begins with a sweet flavor that is difficult to name. There are some nice tobacco notes present and light spice that adds character. The burn is solid, but the draw is tight as expected from this vitola.
At the one quarter point the sweetness has developed well and is reminiscent of coconut. There are still some nice tobacco notes and some spice present as well. The burn is consistent and the draw is still tight.
At the halfway point the cigar has maintained a sweet core, there are still some fleeting tobacco notes. The burn is a bit lopsided, but there does not appear to be any issues on the horizon. The draw opens a little bit affording some more depth to the flavors.
The final half of the cigar proceeds much the same as the first. The sweet profile has maintained it's prominence, and there are notes of spice. The cigar has lacked depth and complexity.
The finish is acceptable with more sweet notes and some light spice.
Appearance- 83 not an attractive cigar
Taste- 86 some lack of depth and complexity hurt this score
Construction- 89 a well made cigar
Strength- 85 an unexpected medium/mild
Overall- 85.75 I expected more
Mi Dominicana by Jose Seijas Corona
This cigar presents with a pale beige wrapper that is almost yellowish in color. There are some prominent veins, but an inspection of the cigar indicates that construction should not be an issue. The pre light aroma shows some floral notes with hints of nuts and spice. The pre light draw shows light pepper and some grassy notes.
The cigar begins with some nice spice and some peppery notes at the back of the palate, the flavors are not deep or complex. The burn is strong, but the draw is tighter than I usually care for, there is a little labor involved to produce smoke.
Two inches into the cigar the core has transitioned into pepper with hints of grass, again the depth, complexity and balance seem off to me. The burn is straight, but the draw has not opened up at all and is causing some heat along the body of the cigar.
At the halfway point the profile shows noted of spice, pepper and grass. An unfortunate metallic note has also surfaced at the back of the palate. The burn is still acceptable and I have slowed down to diminish the heat which is producing less smoke.
The final half of the cigar shows notes of pepper and roasted nuts, but the metallic flavors are hurting the profile. The burn has stayed sharp and the draw opens slightly in the final half.
The finish is acceptable, with notes of pepper and spice. There is still a metallic undertone, but it has diminished.
Appearance- 84 veining and color hurt the score
Taste- 79 grass and metallic notes hurt the score
Construction- 77 draw problems limit the score
Strength- 80 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 80 below average smoke
The cigar begins with some nice spice and some peppery notes at the back of the palate, the flavors are not deep or complex. The burn is strong, but the draw is tighter than I usually care for, there is a little labor involved to produce smoke.
Two inches into the cigar the core has transitioned into pepper with hints of grass, again the depth, complexity and balance seem off to me. The burn is straight, but the draw has not opened up at all and is causing some heat along the body of the cigar.
At the halfway point the profile shows noted of spice, pepper and grass. An unfortunate metallic note has also surfaced at the back of the palate. The burn is still acceptable and I have slowed down to diminish the heat which is producing less smoke.
The final half of the cigar shows notes of pepper and roasted nuts, but the metallic flavors are hurting the profile. The burn has stayed sharp and the draw opens slightly in the final half.
The finish is acceptable, with notes of pepper and spice. There is still a metallic undertone, but it has diminished.
Appearance- 84 veining and color hurt the score
Taste- 79 grass and metallic notes hurt the score
Construction- 77 draw problems limit the score
Strength- 80 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 80 below average smoke
Friday, October 23, 2009
Don Pepin Garcia My Father Le Bijou 1922
This is the new offering in the My Father line, it is a pricier cigar with an $11+ retail. The cigar is beautiful to look at as it is draped in a nice oscuro wrapper that has some prominent veining, but it appears to be well made. The roll seems firm, but supple and the cigar has a nice oily gleam. The pre light aroma has light notes of spice, candy and fruit. The pre light draw has notes of tobacco, earth and spice.
The cigar opens with more strength than I expected. The profile is deep and has flavors of earth, rich tobacco and a sweet candy note at the back of the palate. The burn is a bit slow, but the draw is smooth and easy producing plenty of smoke.
At the one third mark the profile has opened up. There are notes of caramel, spice, tobacco and wood and at the back of the palate a coffee note has presented as well. The burn has become lopsided and I am starting to experience a runner. The draw has stayed smooth and bountiful.
At the halfway point the runner has developed into a full blown canoe, I am still attempting to persevere as I do not want to char the excellent profile of the cigar. The profile is showing notes of earth, tobacco, wood and coffee. The draw has stayed consistent.
With about a third of the cigar left I opt to knock off the canoe instead of relighting. This can be a rather neanderthal approach, but I sometimes go to this move to save the profile. Satisfied that I am past it I refocus. The profile has maintained notes of earth and tobacco, but the caramel notes return in the last third. The draw has stayed easy throughout.
The finish is long and smooth. It showed notes of earth, coffee and tobacco.
Appearance- 90 veining hurt the score
Taste- 94 an excellent, complex profile
Construction- 82 the canoe severely detracts from the score
Strength- 88 stronger than I thought and at times in the way of a wonderfully complex profile
Overall- 88.5 construction hurt the score, but the taste was excellent
The cigar opens with more strength than I expected. The profile is deep and has flavors of earth, rich tobacco and a sweet candy note at the back of the palate. The burn is a bit slow, but the draw is smooth and easy producing plenty of smoke.
At the one third mark the profile has opened up. There are notes of caramel, spice, tobacco and wood and at the back of the palate a coffee note has presented as well. The burn has become lopsided and I am starting to experience a runner. The draw has stayed smooth and bountiful.
At the halfway point the runner has developed into a full blown canoe, I am still attempting to persevere as I do not want to char the excellent profile of the cigar. The profile is showing notes of earth, tobacco, wood and coffee. The draw has stayed consistent.
With about a third of the cigar left I opt to knock off the canoe instead of relighting. This can be a rather neanderthal approach, but I sometimes go to this move to save the profile. Satisfied that I am past it I refocus. The profile has maintained notes of earth and tobacco, but the caramel notes return in the last third. The draw has stayed easy throughout.
The finish is long and smooth. It showed notes of earth, coffee and tobacco.
Appearance- 90 veining hurt the score
Taste- 94 an excellent, complex profile
Construction- 82 the canoe severely detracts from the score
Strength- 88 stronger than I thought and at times in the way of a wonderfully complex profile
Overall- 88.5 construction hurt the score, but the taste was excellent
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Camacho Coyolar Puro Rothchild
This cigar has about a year of humidor aging and is from a box I acquired last fall. The cigar presents with a nice darker brown wrapper that has little, if any, veining. The pre light aroma has notes of earth, spice and roasted nuts. The pre light draw shows a nice earthy note with some undertones of spice.
The cigar begins with a serious burst of power. There are notes of earth, spice and a strong tobacco thread that brings it all together. The draw is superior and it provides ample smoke. The burn is strong and the ash is a sturdy gray. The first inch of the cigar proceeds in excellent fashion.
At the two inch mark the profile has notes of leather, earth, spice and tobacco. The flavor is deep and savory and I am surprised by the complexity and depth of the cigar. The draw and burn continue to be impressive.
Just past the halfway point the profile is showing notes of roasted nuts, leather and tobacco. The draw and burn remain solid to this point. I am continuing to be impressed with this cigar and it is well documented that I am not a fan of Camacho offerings.
The final third of the cigar continues to show notes of leather, roasted nuts and tobacco. There is a little bit of a floral note at the back of the palate. In addition there is a slightly metallic note near the end that is distracting.
The finish is a bit disappointing, showing notes of earth and leather, but there is a metallic note that hurts the experience.
Appearance- 91 an attractive cigar
Taste- 88 some metallic notes at the end and on the finish hurt the score
Construction- 94 an excellent experience
Strength- 87 a very full experience, but it does not compliment the profile well
Overall- 90 an excellent smoking experience
The cigar begins with a serious burst of power. There are notes of earth, spice and a strong tobacco thread that brings it all together. The draw is superior and it provides ample smoke. The burn is strong and the ash is a sturdy gray. The first inch of the cigar proceeds in excellent fashion.
At the two inch mark the profile has notes of leather, earth, spice and tobacco. The flavor is deep and savory and I am surprised by the complexity and depth of the cigar. The draw and burn continue to be impressive.
Just past the halfway point the profile is showing notes of roasted nuts, leather and tobacco. The draw and burn remain solid to this point. I am continuing to be impressed with this cigar and it is well documented that I am not a fan of Camacho offerings.
The final third of the cigar continues to show notes of leather, roasted nuts and tobacco. There is a little bit of a floral note at the back of the palate. In addition there is a slightly metallic note near the end that is distracting.
The finish is a bit disappointing, showing notes of earth and leather, but there is a metallic note that hurts the experience.
Appearance- 91 an attractive cigar
Taste- 88 some metallic notes at the end and on the finish hurt the score
Construction- 94 an excellent experience
Strength- 87 a very full experience, but it does not compliment the profile well
Overall- 90 an excellent smoking experience
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
Vegas Cubana Robusto
This is another Don Pepin offering. The cigar presents with a light beige colored wrapper that has a nice sheen and little veining. The pre light aroma is of cedar. The pre light draw has notes of grass, cedar and earth. The construction appears to be sound and an inspection does not show any areas of concern.
The cigar begins with a loamy profile that has notes of earth and grass. The draw is acceptable, but maybe a little tight. The burn starts out well, but the cigar is a little hot. The first inch and a half maintains the same profile and burn attributes.
At about one third of the way into the cigar the profile picks up some flavors of mushrooms while continuing to present earth and grassy notes. The draw has loosened up and the burn is acceptable.
At the half way point the cigar picks up strength, but the profile remains disappointing. There are notes of earth and grass and a hint of pepper. The draw and burn have remained consistent, as is the tradition of Pepin cigars.
The final half of the cigar maintains an earthy profile, there are notes of grass and pepper. There is some bitterness at the back of the palate and a sour note as well. The burn and draw are still above average.
The finish is short and metallic.
Appearance- 87 a bit off color
Taste- 81 grass and mushroom notes coupled with bitterness at the end hurt the score
Construction- 93 an superbly made cigar
Strength- 85 an average medium
Overall- 86.5 a cigar saved by construction
The cigar begins with a loamy profile that has notes of earth and grass. The draw is acceptable, but maybe a little tight. The burn starts out well, but the cigar is a little hot. The first inch and a half maintains the same profile and burn attributes.
At about one third of the way into the cigar the profile picks up some flavors of mushrooms while continuing to present earth and grassy notes. The draw has loosened up and the burn is acceptable.
At the half way point the cigar picks up strength, but the profile remains disappointing. There are notes of earth and grass and a hint of pepper. The draw and burn have remained consistent, as is the tradition of Pepin cigars.
The final half of the cigar maintains an earthy profile, there are notes of grass and pepper. There is some bitterness at the back of the palate and a sour note as well. The burn and draw are still above average.
The finish is short and metallic.
Appearance- 87 a bit off color
Taste- 81 grass and mushroom notes coupled with bitterness at the end hurt the score
Construction- 93 an superbly made cigar
Strength- 85 an average medium
Overall- 86.5 a cigar saved by construction
Room 101 Robusto by Camacho
This is a new offering from the Eiroa's, I will preface this by saying that it is no secret amongst those that know me that I do not like Camacho cigars. This cigar presents well, it has a nice dark wrapper that appears to have some tooth. An inspection reveals that the cigar seems to be well made, and I detect no soft spots or other flaws. The pre light aroma has notes of anise and spice. The pre light draw shows signs of tobacco and spice.
The cigar begins with a sour note that is off putting, I can't discern any flavors for the first inch or so due to the sour notes. The burn is acceptable and the draw is above average. The cigar progresses in much the same fashion for the first inch, until I get past whatever the sour note was.
At the inch and a half mark the cigar really opens up. The profile shows notes of coffee, anise, spice and tobacco, it is an excellent mix of flavors. The burn has started to stray a bit and it is becoming lopsided. The draw has stayed consistent.
Until I had about three eighths of the cigar left I was enjoying the profile and the smoke, that is when things took a dark turn. I encountered a horrible canoe that nearly made the cigar unsmokeable, it was almost as if the filler on one side was just a bundle of stems. I try to fight through it, to no avail, and gently retouch the cigar by burning out the imperfection. The profile has also turned for the worse. The sour notes had returned before the canoe took place, and they were coupled with notes of paper and grass.
The finish was a bit short, there were muddled notes of grass and paper.
Appearance- 88 an attractive cigar that appears a bit dry
Taste- 83 this only gets this score because of the middle portion, if the rest of the cigar were that good a 90+ score would have been a certainty
Construction- 75 the canoe was one of the worst I have seen
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full presentation
Overall- 83.5 could have been much better
The cigar begins with a sour note that is off putting, I can't discern any flavors for the first inch or so due to the sour notes. The burn is acceptable and the draw is above average. The cigar progresses in much the same fashion for the first inch, until I get past whatever the sour note was.
At the inch and a half mark the cigar really opens up. The profile shows notes of coffee, anise, spice and tobacco, it is an excellent mix of flavors. The burn has started to stray a bit and it is becoming lopsided. The draw has stayed consistent.
Until I had about three eighths of the cigar left I was enjoying the profile and the smoke, that is when things took a dark turn. I encountered a horrible canoe that nearly made the cigar unsmokeable, it was almost as if the filler on one side was just a bundle of stems. I try to fight through it, to no avail, and gently retouch the cigar by burning out the imperfection. The profile has also turned for the worse. The sour notes had returned before the canoe took place, and they were coupled with notes of paper and grass.
The finish was a bit short, there were muddled notes of grass and paper.
Appearance- 88 an attractive cigar that appears a bit dry
Taste- 83 this only gets this score because of the middle portion, if the rest of the cigar were that good a 90+ score would have been a certainty
Construction- 75 the canoe was one of the worst I have seen
Strength- 88 a nice medium/full presentation
Overall- 83.5 could have been much better
Monday, October 19, 2009
El Martillo 2009
I was unable to find much information about the lineage of this cigar, but it appears that it is something due to be released soon. The cigar is big, dark and oily. The wrapper has no flaws and the veining is slight, the cigar is beautiful to look at. The construction appears to be solid, and a quick roll through the fingers shows no signs of any issues. The pre light aroma is distinctly of raisins. The pre light draw is sweet and has notes of tobacco, earth and hard candy.
The cigar begins with notes of rich tobacco, earth and a light sweetness. The draw is acceptable and the burn is sharp. The first inch of the cigar maintains the above profile and burn characteristics.
At just past the one third point the profile develops with notes of dark wood, earth and straight blasts of rich tobacco. There is a slightly dirty or ashy flavor that is sneaking onto the back of the palate and I am worried about some nasty aftertaste on the finish. The draw and the burn are holding up well, but there is some labor in both, it almost seems as if the cigar is moist.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of wood, earth and tobacco. The ashy notes have become prominent and they are detracting from the overall experience. The burn and draw continue to be laborious, and are getting more so, the closer to the end of the smoke I progress.
The finish is short and dirty, with ashy flavors and a muddy undertone.
Appearance- 92 an excellent looking cigar
Taste- 77 the ashy notes in the profile and the muddy finish hurt the score
Construction- 79 some burn and draw issues caused labor to produce a pleasing amount of smoke
Strength- 83 a full offering that did not compliment the profile well
Overall- 82.75 not very good, saved by the appearance score
The cigar begins with notes of rich tobacco, earth and a light sweetness. The draw is acceptable and the burn is sharp. The first inch of the cigar maintains the above profile and burn characteristics.
At just past the one third point the profile develops with notes of dark wood, earth and straight blasts of rich tobacco. There is a slightly dirty or ashy flavor that is sneaking onto the back of the palate and I am worried about some nasty aftertaste on the finish. The draw and the burn are holding up well, but there is some labor in both, it almost seems as if the cigar is moist.
The final half of the cigar continues to show notes of wood, earth and tobacco. The ashy notes have become prominent and they are detracting from the overall experience. The burn and draw continue to be laborious, and are getting more so, the closer to the end of the smoke I progress.
The finish is short and dirty, with ashy flavors and a muddy undertone.
Appearance- 92 an excellent looking cigar
Taste- 77 the ashy notes in the profile and the muddy finish hurt the score
Construction- 79 some burn and draw issues caused labor to produce a pleasing amount of smoke
Strength- 83 a full offering that did not compliment the profile well
Overall- 82.75 not very good, saved by the appearance score
Savinelli Special Selection 2005 Torpedo
This cigar presents as a giant torpedo with a slightly lopsided look and a slightly rounded head. The wrapper looks dark and bold, but there are some prominent veins and some minor wrapper flaws. The pre light aroma is fruity and has notes of tobacco and spice. The pre light draw is sweet and has hints of fruit.
Upon lighting this cigar begins to deliver notes of tobacco, spice and dark fruit. The draw is decent and the burn begins well. I detect a slight bitter note at the back of the palate, but it is not prominent or overwhelming. The first inch and a half of the cigar performs well, but I am hoping for some development in the final two thirds.
The middle third of the cigar continues to show notes of tobacco and fruit. There is some further development of a tobacco note, but the flavors are shallow and thready. The draw has stayed consistent, but the burn has started to run a bit, but does not yet require attention.
The final third of the cigar continues to show the run that was beginning in the middle third, but I am still trying to smoke through it. The profile has begun to show notes of pepper, tobacco and earth. There is still a bitterness through the nose and at the back of the palate. The draw and burn stayed consistent throughout.
The finish is short and a bit acrid, it shows notes of pepper and tobacco.
Appearance- 84 not the most attractive of cigars
Taste- 83 some bitter notes and a poor finish hurt the score, but the profile showed promise
Construction- 83 some burn issues hurt the score
Strength- 86 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 84 a slightly below average offering
Upon lighting this cigar begins to deliver notes of tobacco, spice and dark fruit. The draw is decent and the burn begins well. I detect a slight bitter note at the back of the palate, but it is not prominent or overwhelming. The first inch and a half of the cigar performs well, but I am hoping for some development in the final two thirds.
The middle third of the cigar continues to show notes of tobacco and fruit. There is some further development of a tobacco note, but the flavors are shallow and thready. The draw has stayed consistent, but the burn has started to run a bit, but does not yet require attention.
The final third of the cigar continues to show the run that was beginning in the middle third, but I am still trying to smoke through it. The profile has begun to show notes of pepper, tobacco and earth. There is still a bitterness through the nose and at the back of the palate. The draw and burn stayed consistent throughout.
The finish is short and a bit acrid, it shows notes of pepper and tobacco.
Appearance- 84 not the most attractive of cigars
Taste- 83 some bitter notes and a poor finish hurt the score, but the profile showed promise
Construction- 83 some burn issues hurt the score
Strength- 86 an unremarkable medium/full
Overall- 84 a slightly below average offering
Sunday, October 18, 2009
Partagas Culebras (2006 Box Date)
This is a vitola that I have always wanted to experience. These come bundled together in sets of three cigars, for my birthday I was given one and shared it with two of my closest friends. The long, curly presentation reminds me of a vine or the crooked finger of an animated witch. There are no flaws in the wrapper and the cigar appears to be well made. The pre light aroma is leathery with hints of spice. The pre light draw is smooth and even, which surprises me because of the twists and turns in the body of the smoke, and has notes of tobacco, spice and leather.
The cigar begins with a profile of leather and earth. The weird vitola draws exceptionally well and booms out billowing pillows of smoke. The burn is also surprisingly sharp, despite the fact that it juts at a forty five degree angle up and away from my mouth. The cigar maintains this status until the halfway point.
In the second half of the cigar the crooks and turns straighten a little, I can only assume that the heat helps this process. The profile is still of leather and earth, but there is some light spice and a satisfying nicotine tingle. The burn and draw have continued to perform well above what I expected from this strange vitola.
The finish is smooth and long with notes of spice, earth and leather.
Appearance- 98 just look at one of these and you will be entertained and wonder how they do it
Taste- 91 a nice solid profile that could use more depth and complexity
Construction- 100 the only score possible for a cigar that performs this well after being twisted and turned
Strength- 90 a nice medium/full smoke
Overall- 94.75 this cigar was the most smoking fun I have had in quite some time
The cigar begins with a profile of leather and earth. The weird vitola draws exceptionally well and booms out billowing pillows of smoke. The burn is also surprisingly sharp, despite the fact that it juts at a forty five degree angle up and away from my mouth. The cigar maintains this status until the halfway point.
In the second half of the cigar the crooks and turns straighten a little, I can only assume that the heat helps this process. The profile is still of leather and earth, but there is some light spice and a satisfying nicotine tingle. The burn and draw have continued to perform well above what I expected from this strange vitola.
The finish is smooth and long with notes of spice, earth and leather.
Appearance- 98 just look at one of these and you will be entertained and wonder how they do it
Taste- 91 a nice solid profile that could use more depth and complexity
Construction- 100 the only score possible for a cigar that performs this well after being twisted and turned
Strength- 90 a nice medium/full smoke
Overall- 94.75 this cigar was the most smoking fun I have had in quite some time
Partagas Short (January 2009 Box Date)
This small cigar presents in a whimsical size for when you have less than thirty minutes for a smoke. The wrapper is toothy and prominently veined, there are also a few flaws in the presentation. The pre light aroma has notes of earth, leather and spice. The pre light draw smacks of tobacco and spice, but there is a metallic note there as well.
The cigar begins with more strength that I would usually anticipate from a cigar of this size. The profile has a core of leathery flavors, but there is some spice at the back of the palate. There is also a bitter, metallic bite on the palate that is hurting the experience. The draw is flawless and the burn, while a bit lopsided, is strong.
This cigar is so short that I can't review it in sections as I normally would. The profile continues hold a core of leathery flavors with some spates of spice, but the bitter notes are still detracting from the experience. I believe that this cigar needs more time, so I will be laying them down for awhile.
The finish is an explosion of nicotine and tobacco, but there is a metallic undertone that again hurts the score.
Appearance- 85 some flaws and veins hurt the score
Taste- 82 the overall core of the profile was excellent, but the metallic bite kills the profile
Construction- 91 this cigar performed extremely well aside from some flaking ashes
Strength- 87 a bit overwhelming from a cigar this size, with age this will mellow to the correct strength to profile ratio
Overall- 86.25 a score based largely on being saved by construction
The cigar begins with more strength that I would usually anticipate from a cigar of this size. The profile has a core of leathery flavors, but there is some spice at the back of the palate. There is also a bitter, metallic bite on the palate that is hurting the experience. The draw is flawless and the burn, while a bit lopsided, is strong.
This cigar is so short that I can't review it in sections as I normally would. The profile continues hold a core of leathery flavors with some spates of spice, but the bitter notes are still detracting from the experience. I believe that this cigar needs more time, so I will be laying them down for awhile.
The finish is an explosion of nicotine and tobacco, but there is a metallic undertone that again hurts the score.
Appearance- 85 some flaws and veins hurt the score
Taste- 82 the overall core of the profile was excellent, but the metallic bite kills the profile
Construction- 91 this cigar performed extremely well aside from some flaking ashes
Strength- 87 a bit overwhelming from a cigar this size, with age this will mellow to the correct strength to profile ratio
Overall- 86.25 a score based largely on being saved by construction
Saturday, October 17, 2009
Trinidad Colonial (January 2009 Box Date)
This cigar presents in a corona size and is finished with a pigtail cap. The wrapper has some minor flaws, and the roll seems a bit tight. The pre light aroma has hints of cinnamon and light spice. The pre light draw is slightly floral, but has some notes of cinnamon and nicotine.
The cigar begins with a complex profile that shows notes of cinnamon, leather and a floral essence. The is some clove at the back of the palate that is adding to the complexity. The burn is sharp, but the draw is tight in the first inch or so.
At the one third point the profile is maintaining it's complex character. There are flavors of cinnamon, leather and clove and it is very complex and deep for a cigar of such small stature. The burn is strong and the draw has opened up a little bit. The smoke is smooth and thick, coating the palate with flavors.
At the one half mark the core of flavors is leathery with notes of tobacco and spice, there are still notes of cinnamon laced throughout the profile. The burn is even and the draw continues to loosen up.
The final half of the cigar continues to show a sturdy profile of leather, tobacco, spice and cinnamon. The strength of the cigar is surprising and it has developed from a mild/medium experience at the start to a medium/full experience at the end. The burn is uneven at this point, but a light touch up corrects the issue. The draw has opened up fully and the cigar booms satisfying clouds of smoke.
The finish is bit short, but there are still notes of tobacco and leather coating the palate.
Appearance- 88 a nice looking cigar with some minor wrapper flaws
Taste- 94 an excellent profile of complex, deep flavors
Construction- 91 the burn issue at the end causes a small deduction
Strength- 95 an excellent evolved strength over the entire body of the smoke
Overall- 92 an excellent cigar with fantastic aging potential
The cigar begins with a complex profile that shows notes of cinnamon, leather and a floral essence. The is some clove at the back of the palate that is adding to the complexity. The burn is sharp, but the draw is tight in the first inch or so.
At the one third point the profile is maintaining it's complex character. There are flavors of cinnamon, leather and clove and it is very complex and deep for a cigar of such small stature. The burn is strong and the draw has opened up a little bit. The smoke is smooth and thick, coating the palate with flavors.
At the one half mark the core of flavors is leathery with notes of tobacco and spice, there are still notes of cinnamon laced throughout the profile. The burn is even and the draw continues to loosen up.
The final half of the cigar continues to show a sturdy profile of leather, tobacco, spice and cinnamon. The strength of the cigar is surprising and it has developed from a mild/medium experience at the start to a medium/full experience at the end. The burn is uneven at this point, but a light touch up corrects the issue. The draw has opened up fully and the cigar booms satisfying clouds of smoke.
The finish is bit short, but there are still notes of tobacco and leather coating the palate.
Appearance- 88 a nice looking cigar with some minor wrapper flaws
Taste- 94 an excellent profile of complex, deep flavors
Construction- 91 the burn issue at the end causes a small deduction
Strength- 95 an excellent evolved strength over the entire body of the smoke
Overall- 92 an excellent cigar with fantastic aging potential
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)